I'm a big fan of Kanye's post MBDTF stuff (though he will never get a dime from me, bootleg only).
TLOP is a 9/10 to me even though its a fukking mess. Classic songs all over that album.
Yeezus is a 8.5/10 to me. A few misses and some shyt lyrics, but still a daring and challenging album with big high points
So with that being said to put my opinion in context, I find YE to be......solid, I guess. Definitely not great. And I completely understand anyone who call it trash even though I don't agree.
I'm glad he stayed experimental instead of going backwards like many people want. But in this case the final product falls a bit flat in spots
fukk what anyone says, that first track is FIRE
After that, its up and down. If an album is sub 25 minutes it has to be brilliant from start to finish.
I am not even going to attempt to rate it yet because of the type of album it is. Songs like this need to marinate to either see if the "earworm" catches you or if it turns into a weedplate
This could be anywhere from a 6 to an 8 for me when its all said and done.
EDIT: 2nd listen and the earworms are already starting to dig...

....thought All Mine was weak on first listen but like it a lot on 2nd listen...this is definitely going to be an 8/10 I think