coli told me rings were a team accomplishmentLT 2 rings. montana 4 rings
objectively speaking montana was better in the 80's
and we've seen brady, manning, rodgers, montana, elway and etc win the game by themselves. brady in the 4th qtr down by 14pts still have a chance to win the game. manning with ball in his hands will come back and break teams heart. rodgers down by 6 will beat you with his leg and his accurate 50+ yard bombs.
i'm sure LT won a game by himself here and there, but great QBs do it multiple times every damn year
Lawrence Taylor is the GOAT football player
- Thread starter Brozay
- Start date
NYC Rebel
...on the otherside of the pond
As a bigtime 49er fan in the 80s, NO TEAM scared you more than the Giants. Maybe you forgot that the Giants had a WINNING RECORD vs the 49ers in the playoffs during the 80s. Thats why your ring counting doesnt mean shyt here. The REAL super bowls were the NFC playoffs back then because the AFC wasnt shyt.LT 2 rings. montana 4 rings
objectively speaking montana was better in the 80's
and we've seen brady, manning, rodgers, montana, elway and etc win the game by themselves. brady in the 4th qtr down by 14pts still have a chance to win the game. manning with ball in his hands will come back and break teams heart. rodgers down by 6 will beat you with his leg and his accurate 50+ yard bombs.
i'm sure LT won a game by himself here and there, but great QBs do it multiple times every damn year
it is a team accomplishment, but down by 10, 4 min to go in the SB, pats fans don't even sweat because of brady. you gotta have the field general who will lead them to the promise land to win the SB.
so you would rather have LT over montana?
head to head match up don't do nothing for me
brady got a losing record against the panthers. and it's not like giants were dominant every year
if they were so dominant they should have more than 2 SB appearances and more playoff success.
LT is the top 3 greatest defensive player ever. no doubt. but i'll take the great QB over him no matter what.
NYC Rebel
...on the otherside of the pond
Im telling you to disqualify that bullshyt ring argument because ifs proven flawed. Bringing up Brady and the panthers as if theyre in the same division and meet in the playoffs.so you would rather have LT over montana?
head to head match up don't do nothing for me
and it's not like giants were dominant every year
if they were so dominant they should have more than 2 SB appearances and more playoff success.
LT is the top 3 greatest defensive player ever. no doubt. but i'll take the great QB over him no matter what.
What ia it about you dises in here that cant fall back and say “ok....youre right on that point”
Montana lost more playoff games vs the Giants and LT than won them. They also played in a tougher division than Montana’s Niners. fukk rings.
Im telling you to disqualify that ######## ring argument because ifs proven flawed. Bringing up Brady and the panthers as if theyre in the same division and meet in the playoffs.
What ia it about you dises in here that cant fall back and say “ok....youre right on that point”
Montana lost more playoff games vs the Giants and LT than won them. They also played in a tougher division than Montana’s Niners. fukk rings.
montana is 6-2 against the giants tho
Joe Montana Career Splits | Pro-Football-Reference.com
you saying rings don't matter at all?
brady is brady cuz he went to 8SBs and won 5 of them. winning ring more important than anything else for the QBs. but it don't matter that much for defesive player cuz we all know defensive players aint as important as the QB.and you haven't answered my question. you would take LT over montana for your niners?
NYC Rebel
...on the otherside of the pond
Im saying ring dont matter in a 53 man team game like football. Its bullshyt. Rings dont make a player better than the other. Niners were just as good with Steve as they were with Joe.montana is 6-2 against the giants tho
Joe Montana Career Splits | Pro-Football-Reference.com
you saying rings don't matter at all?
and you haven't answered my question. you would take LT over montana for your niners?
NYC Rebel
...on the otherside of the pond
You brought up rings. On the playoff road to them, Joe lost more than he won facing LT and them.so that makes him 8-5 against the giants including regular season and the playoffs.
Again...you refuse to adjust.
i already told you head to head don't matter.
is manning better than brady cuz manning beat him 2-3 in the playoffs?
and of course i brought up rings. rings are part of a GOAT discussion. if you ain't got a ring, you ain't no goat. montana won 4 and played flawlessly in those SBs. that's more important to me than anything else.
Last edited:
NYC Rebel
...on the otherside of the pond
i already told you head to head don't matter.
is manning better than brady cuz manning beat him 2-3 in the playoffs?
I said rings dont matter and Manning has lost more to the pats.
Again...you brought rings which is a team accomplishment. You can argue that Montana wasnt even the best player on his own team
so changing the game is a criteria for the GOAT?
Yes changing the game has a bit to play in it, tell me straight up that Brady and/or Rodgers had changed the game more than LT has
OK how about being defensive rookie of the year + NFL defensive player of the year in the SAME fukkING SEASON
How about being a LEAGUE MVP as a defensive player, something I think only 2 other players have done in history
How about having more All pro 8 times (more than brady)
NYC Rebel
...on the otherside of the pond
Especially when facing LT’s Giants, Montana lost more times than he won. This play literally forced the Niners to sign Steve Young as a back up so they could have security.Yes changing the game has a bit to play in it, tell me straight up that Brady and/or Rodgers had changed the game more than LT has
OK how about being defensive rookie of the year + NFL defensive player of the year in the SAME fukkING SEASON
How about being a LEAGUE MVP as a defensive player, something I think only 2 other players have done in history
How about having more All pro 8 times (more than brady)
Last edited: