I think it's a decent idea.
Whilst the okayplayer boards have horrible 90s formatting and some bitter dusty backpackers, I've always liked how they combined discussion of all genres and had a more respectful tone that encouraged deeper discussion.
Only problem is it being a subforum. Subforums rarely become popular. I guess there's a couple of exceptions like TSC but generally people ignore subforums.
Whilst the okayplayer boards have horrible 90s formatting and some bitter dusty backpackers, I've always liked how they combined discussion of all genres and had a more respectful tone that encouraged deeper discussion.
Only problem is it being a subforum. Subforums rarely become popular. I guess there's a couple of exceptions like TSC but generally people ignore subforums.