1. Breh...you don't even understand your argument let alone mine. What's your point in saying that Obama's deified if it's not to imply that Republicans were somehow more "honest" or clear in thinking in their dealings with Bush? Quite simply, what's your point if it's not that Obama shouldn't be receiving as much support as he is? You're talking about people not even talking about earmarks in a healthcare bill and then pointing to approval rating polls as if the people being called by Gallup et al on ANY side (democratic or republican) is getting into that level of detail. Bush had massive, easily digestible and visible fukkups and Obama didn't. YOU are the one who brought up approval ratings. Why is this so hard for you to understand?
2. Not sure what your point is. White working class people can leave the democratic party without Obama's approval ratings plummeting. What's your point?
3. This is a non-sequitur. So? My argument, that you seem to be struggling with, is wholly around addressing your implication that Obama is getting a "pass" that Bush didn't get as evidenced by approval ratings, commentary, etc. I'm saying that Obama gets a pass because he's been smart enough to not deploy huge number of ground troops and keep his wars "sanitary" for public consumption.
Prosecuting a war via drones and small numbers of forces isn't the received the same way as prosecuting one via deploying a ground invasion, no matter how much you think it should be. If Obama had invaded Syria over the questionable sarin gas episode you'd have a much stronger point.
4. My point is that you're suggesting the state of the economy now is somehow comparable to what it was when Bush left. Why do you keep bringing up poll numbers if the point isn't that Obama's getting a pass Bush wouldn't???
Tell me if this is not your rationale:
1. Obama and Bush have had more or less similar levels of efficacy as presidents with respect to satisfying their respective constituencies in the general public
Your supporting rationale with the unstated rationale that you have yet to address in the parentheses:
- They've both gone to war (i.e. people don't have different appetites for drone / "limited" wars vs. ground invasions)
- Obama's healthcare plan came up short in ways that his base cared about just as much as Bush's base cared about controlling spending and being hard on immigration (i.e., democratic constituencies care as much about premiums rising as republican constituencies care about the country not being tougher on immigration)
- The economy's not doing great under Obama and it wasn't doing great under Bush (i.e. the average American's situation is just as poor today as it was under Bush)
2. However, Obama has a higher approval rating than Bush did at the same point in Bush's presidency
3. Therefore, Obama's constituency is giving Obama a pass that Bush's constituency did not give him