Lets settle this once and for all: Randall Cunningham or Michael Vick?

[Arcavian]

Randall is the reason I started fukking with the eagles

 

[RhodyRum]

Wasn't old enough to catch Randall, Vick by default.
McNabb is the GOAT Black QB though.

One big game with it all on the line. You take McNabb over the man pictured above?

 

[Ice Cold]

Rambling, scrambling Randall Cunningham. I barely remember him playing but man what was it tecmo bowl?

 

[Trip]

Rambling, scrambling Randall Cunningham. I barely remember him playing but man what was it tecmo bowl?

"QB Eagles"

 

[Captain Crunch]

One big game with it all on the line. You take McNabb over the man pictured above?

Save for the SB, he's been big for them, he did all he could w/ no receivers and idiot coaching.
Both are HoF'ers, but Prime McNabb is an elite qb, just a slight notch over McNair.

 

[JLova]

Randal. More complete QB. More durable, made better decisions, more swag.

 

[Trip]

Save for the SB, he's been big for them, he did all he could w/ no receivers and idiot coaching.
Both are HoF'ers, but Prime McNabb is an elite qb, just a slight notch over McNair.

McNair as a HOF'er is a stretch

 

[QuintessentialBM]

Cunningham and it ain't even close....

 

[JLova]

One big game with it all on the line. You take McNabb over the man pictured above?

McNabb > McNair

 

[RhodyRum]

Save for the SB, he's been big for them, he did all he could w/ no receivers and idiot coaching.
Both are HoF'ers, but Prime McNabb is an elite qb, just a slight notch over McNair.

The funny thing is you can switch McNabb & McNair in what you wrote and both are pretty congruent & good arguments. They did seem to have virtually parallel careers.

 

[Captain Crunch]

McNair as a HOF'er is a stretch

Didn't watch NFL in the 00's post

 

[Trip]

Not for nothing but Vick still has a chance todo something....

 

[Primetime21]

I thought thread was about Cunningham or Vick

 

[Boolean]

we need negs back

Farkenton as the best scrambler ever

McNair over McNabb

 

[Black White Sox Hat]

those kelly green Eagle unis

Those eagles zubaz pants