Let's talk about the hilariously bad basketball scene from American History X

GoddamnyamanProf

Countdown to Armageddon
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
35,793
Reputation
878
Daps
106,213
and this is why you hire consultants for your movies. im sure somebody who had actually watched a basketball game in their life could have choreographed a more believable scene where a team with an incredibly out of shape guy, and a shorty manage to win.

it's as bad as most movies where somebody plays an instrument or draws a picture, but the actor and director have no idea how to really do those activities. you just have to forget what you just saw, LOL.
Basketball is by far the hardest sport to "fake." I can tell whether someone knows how to play basketball after watching them handle a ball for about 3 seconds. Movies/shows where someone is supposed to be really good and they're doing that struggle dribble :dead:
 

Hersh

Superstar
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
20,529
Reputation
3,011
Daps
33,453
You guys have no clue. :smh: Missed the premise.







The Black & white scenes[Bball scene,curb stomp..] are being viewed in hindsight by his little brother as he writes the story for the principal, in his head he views his brother as a hero who always wins & he can admire.... thats why the Basketball scene is INTENTIONALLY unrealistic; Danny is viewing it through his memories and he sees his big bro[in prison at the time] as the hero figure but late in the movie when he is released from prison he has a clear perception of who his big brother really is, a convicted murderer.

:ehh: buildings crushed
 

SwagKingKong

All Star
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
4,442
Reputation
181
Daps
6,380
You guys have no clue. :smh: Missed the premise.







The Black & white scenes[Bball scene,curb stomp..] are being viewed in hindsight by his little brother as he writes the story for the principal, in his head he views his brother as a hero who always wins & he can admire.... thats why the Basketball scene is INTENTIONALLY unrealistic; Danny is viewing it through his memories and he sees his big bro[in prison at the time] as the hero figure but late in the movie when he is released from prison he has a clear perception of who his big brother really is, a convicted murderer.

:whoa:
 

Wise

All Star
Joined
Jun 30, 2012
Messages
7,632
Reputation
777
Daps
11,091
Reppin
NULL
Very good film - top 20. Looking back though I can see how this is corny.

As far as good scenes, my favourite was when Derek was leaving jail and the convo he had with his black friend from the laundry. One of my fav scenes in film history.
 

nieman

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2012
Messages
18,005
Reputation
2,646
Daps
35,837
Reppin
Philly
Basketball is by far the hardest sport to "fake." I can tell whether someone knows how to play basketball after watching them handle a ball for about 3 seconds. Movies/shows where someone is supposed to be really good and they're doing that struggle dribble :dead:

This is why I hate basketball movies without legit ballers. Plenty of actors can play ball, sh!t cast them as extras. Between watching them dribble or that first step, it's atrocious if they can't play. Also, the black buls in the movie couldn't play either.

How is this movie receiving so much hate? The amount of tension delivered throughout every scene in this movie...it's definitely upper echelon of films. It makes my Top 50
 

Savior

Superstar
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
4,946
Reputation
1,030
Daps
12,877
Reppin
#byrdgang
It was a good movie....it def did a better job than any movie Ive seen showing how racism is getting spread on the low. With dude's dad always shytting on black people at the dinner table. People ain't born racist but think about how many white parents are talking about "black people only got where they are cause of affirmitave action" around their kids, what do u expect them to think after that. Racism ain't always gotta be on some neo-nazi lynch nikkas shyt to be dangerous this movie did a good job showing that at times.
 

yseJ

Empire strikes back
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
47,163
Reputation
2,894
Daps
69,677
Reppin
The Yay
Never liked the movie like that, always thought it was overrated, by closet racists and people who wanted to be edgy, or who really didn't know much about movies in general, but wanted to add to the conversation....
funny, because the movie is pretty much anti-fascist/anti-racist.

sounds like you're being one of those people who "wanted to add to the conversation" :heh:
 

yseJ

Empire strikes back
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
47,163
Reputation
2,894
Daps
69,677
Reppin
The Yay
You guys have no clue. :smh: Missed the premise.







The Black & white scenes[Bball scene,curb stomp..] are being viewed in hindsight by his little brother as he writes the story for the principal, in his head he views his brother as a hero who always wins & he can admire.... thats why the Basketball scene is INTENTIONALLY unrealistic; Danny is viewing it through his memories and he sees his big bro[in prison at the time] as the hero figure but late in the movie when he is released from prison he has a clear perception of who his big brother really is, a convicted murderer.

breh people still think movie is a glorification of racism, and u tryin to kick knowledge around here ? :shaq2:
 

re'up

Veteran
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
21,291
Reputation
6,563
Daps
67,062
Reppin
San Diego
funny, because the movie is pretty much anti-fascist/anti-racist.

sounds like you're being one of those people who "wanted to add to the conversation" :heh:

Maybe it wasn't your experience, but I remember when that movie came out, and then was released on VHS, lol it was that long ago..A LOT of kids I knew loved, who weren't maybe all out racists but definitely had those tendencies...when everyone just talks about the stomp scene, you know there some disconnect between the medium and the message.
 

yseJ

Empire strikes back
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
47,163
Reputation
2,894
Daps
69,677
Reppin
The Yay
Maybe it wasn't your experience, but I remember when that movie came out, and then was released on VHS, lol it was that long ago..A LOT of kids I knew loved, who weren't maybe all out racists but definitely had those tendencies...when everyone just talks about the stomp scene, you know there some disconnect between the medium and the message.

just because the movie is anti-racist/anti-fascist doesnt mean it has to scream in your face and be PC

the reason its a great movie is because it communicates the message in a powerful, but also very mature way.

it doesnt throw morals at you, just shows shyt as is... and a racist/fascists persons realization of how his beliefs were wrong, through his experience.

some people only remembering the stomp scene shows what THEY got out of the movie.
 

We Ready

The Malarkey Cutter
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
15,771
Reputation
6,131
Daps
32,538
Reppin
Indiana
iYQz0ty6N8RnG.gif



izgB7Y9nXNxAQ.gif
 

up in here

Superstar
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
7,710
Reputation
2,406
Daps
20,290
Reppin
NULL
You guys have no clue. :smh: Missed the premise.







The Black & white scenes[Bball scene,curb stomp..] are being viewed in hindsight by his little brother as he writes the story for the principal, in his head he views his brother as a hero who always wins & he can admire.... thats why the Basketball scene is INTENTIONALLY unrealistic; Danny is viewing it through his memories and he sees his big bro[in prison at the time] as the hero figure but late in the movie when he is released from prison he has a clear perception of who his big brother really is, a convicted murderer.

Damn that went right over my head. I always thought the scene was BS but it makes sense now
 
Top