The best ones retired.
Jericho was over the first few years he was in the WWE but after that he was a career mid-carder until his HBK program. If he was top ten of all time over he would have been a perennial main eventer. He never got reactions to warrant being in the top ten of all time and certainly was never as over as Bryan and Punk.
Imo, Jericho at his best was good to very good, but spent most of his career kind of half assing it or being awkward. He was always clearly a rung below the top WCW midcard talent, and he really didn't mesh with a lot of guys in WCW or WWE. His best role was as a comedy midcarder and the only time I ever bought him as a true main event guy was during his feud with Rock.
He's a hipster wrestling fan. There's no damn way Lawler is 6th all time in the ring.



It keeps their bond special, what a father