I'm probably going to take heat for this, but MBDTF is my favorite album of all time. All time periods, all genres of music, etc. Its got great replay value, I probably listen to it still a couple times a week. I would consider myself a pretty big Kanye West fan, but wouldn't consider myself a Stan.
If I had to rank all his records, it would go like this:
MBDTF
College Dropout
Graduation
808s
Late Registration
I would put WTT between Graduation and 808s, and I would put Cruel Summer last, even though they are both pretty good.