Melo vs Dominique Wilkins

Lord_Chief_Rocka

Superstar
Joined
Apr 20, 2015
Messages
17,727
Reputation
1,500
Daps
50,003
It’s funny seeing the same people who downplay rings now saying Nique can’t be better than Bird, Bron, and KD

Before nique got injured his numbers were comparable and he didn’t play with the same level of support
 

nieman

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2012
Messages
18,076
Reputation
2,736
Daps
36,017
Reppin
Philly
It's a tie based on their eras, but Melo was better than Nique. There numbers are virtually identical, but Melo was a more versatile scorer. Nique's jumper was shaky as hell. But he is arguably the best finisher ever, and if not, I see him no lower than 3.

Why do people keep putting Pippen in the discussion for best 3s? He's not on their level - He's not Bird, Doc, Bron...Not KD, Barry, not Melo, Nique...hell...you can make the argument for Chis Mullin over Pippen too. Pippen is the greatest complimentary player.
 

seemorecizzy

Superstar
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
16,776
Reputation
2,622
Daps
54,642
Reppin
NULL
Nique


Better comparison to Melo imo is Glenn Big Dog Robinson
:dead:
fam, go back and look at their career accomplishments, stats, and even playin style.
they play nothin alike
people make that comparison strictly due to body type:deadrose:

glenn robinson isnt comparable to melo

melo and nique is a very respectable discussion. they have identical stats.
same scoring avg,
both have a scoring title
,melo has 10 allstar appearances, dom has 9,
dom has 7 all nba appearances, melo has 6
i mean got damn, both of them were drafted third in the draft:russ:

wilkens, just like melo, didnt have the super teams like bird magic isiah and therefore didnt win any rings. difference is, back then players were respected for their talent, ring or no ring.
nowadays its a joke
 

GreatestLaker

#FirePelinka
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
22,172
Reputation
1,065
Daps
44,290
Carmelo was not better than nique and in history pound for pound at the three.
Nique is the actual best all time advanced skill player at the three, period.

Anyone naysaying,...i know you young as fukk.

Also no,...kd, Melo, bron are not better than nique. They never lead the league in scoring in timeline to even rival nique.
Nor do they have any duels on the level of nique versus mike neither.


I know you nikkaz ain't see no fukk'n nique with this bullshyt for bron and kd.

Two cats who physically don't even master their natural position to even play their natural.
nikkaz making excuses for bron at the three shirk'n responsibilities and his natural at the one. Just for starters. Not to mention in the era nique played. He saw way tougher competition with way higher bball iq's as well.

You nikkaz ain't watch this shyt just like you nikkaz never dig in the crate.

Stop...you not fooling nobody with this refugee forums shyt.
We can compare in timeline and you will lose.
before we even get to the new wave player bytchassness. Coupled with low bball IQ era rules changes and more tacked on to it to draw revelence to how wrong you lil non knowin nikkaz are.

We can bring up the tape you nikkaz never watch to compare too.



Art Barr
That argument that we're too young to rate Nique holds no weight. There are millions of people out there who watched Nique in his prime and NONE of them have him over Lebron, Kobe, Durant, Bird etc.
 

Art Barr

INVADING SOHH CHAMPION
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
72,060
Reputation
15,088
Daps
100,297
Reppin
CHICAGO
:mjlol:



I'll concede that Bird get more props for being a white player but during Jordan's rookie year, Bird was on his first of 3 straight MVPs while leading the C's to a league best record and a NBA finals berth.

just the fact you tried this whole split shyt up shyt..shows you really not adept at these convos and I know you really ain't had these convos in real time versus no real bball aficionados at all ever like me.

I will go through here and show you your disconnect cause I know one exists because this Gen does not dig in the crate. When the crate got an interface, new digital field to search and resembles the Pixar digital look you nikkaz all been fooled into thinking is the only look. Yet and still I will go through just to show you and present what you don't know and to ramp. I give full shyt and since you took the time albeit misguided and full of disconnect. I will take the time to learn you young in.


Art Barr



I.AM.PIFF said:
This seems more like an aesthetic preference than being most effective on the court.

since you took this out of context.
Just to think you know but don't imma easily squelch this.

I know you could have never seen nique. Plus really do not have a good frame of reference. To even speak on this. As stylistically Harold minor looked good but Kobe was able to establish the difference between style and execution. I think you missed the whole Jordan clone thing before Kobe. So right here it shows you gotta disconnect.
As we discussing nique but you downplaying him just off top. Lets me know you never saw the shyt like that.
Plus you don't know nique lead the league in scoring vfore Jordan. So if nique was that guy before mike as a skill player. When did the other players trump nique as a skill player.
There is a reason I outline the goat argument numerous times here. Plus explain the connotation of what the goat is.
as it was created to misappropriate bill Russell for bird.
In that, you fell into the white media created bird argument.
Bird is bird on here because I fleshed bird out here, in this realm.
As a skill player, team player and world builder and his reputation. Before I did that people discredited bird, here.
So all the bird love is based off of me.
So anyone trying to use bird out of context I know off top.
Plus how it easily trickles down to nique.
so now here we are with nique. Who was a better actual skill player than bird. Bird had better resources, he was not a better skill player than nique.

I.AM.PIFF said:
Your wording is always confusing. Are you implying Magic is the 2nd greatest point guard of all time after Dr. J?

NO, you missed that after dr j and magic.
Was nique.
Before Michael.

That is what you missed.
You told on yourself.

It is like when people try to post about po pimp twista and don't know about prt's rock this fukkee joint playing into whom twista is at his core.

Same here, you should know how and what happened from the grassroots and be prescient about that knowledge. In this instance, your NBA history skips over the players between dr j to magic/bird to Michael.
Which is why you have disconnect on nique of all people.
When mike was around even with magic and bird and drj. The next topic of discussion was nique and he was singularly the next best player after mike and before mike singularly the best skill plauer. He was evolved dr j.

You are talking about history.
as if it is a children us public school based social studies book. That just goes from BC to ad in a paragraph and picture of a dinosaur to explain the difference. You are missing kernels of the grassroots journey.
At least in bball, we can definitively go back and see the skill players and your posting shows you skipped eras and ball players. shyt just the disservice to nique period is on display in this thread. Melo was never nique. He has comparison to nique because similarly mike/nique used to be transposed into bron/melo. Before the NYC eastern seaboard witch hunt of Melo began when he was a knick.


I.AM.PIFF said:
That's a large claim to make considering Nique wasn't even the ROY and didn't even make an all star game till his fourth year in the league. Bird & Mike were stars the instants they set foot in the league.


stop.
Back then in position nique was behind in team win and a look compared to guys with winning proven orgs and records to boot. This is an exposal because you should know the dispersal of power and why to even comment on this. Which you brought it up devoid of this knowledge. If you knew this and this is another example of your disconnect. You would have known this beforehand in a black basketball player discussion.
Plus real talk,....i am the only person who really talks about the real game of basketball in every aspect down to the parochial vs public and many more.
So I know that knowledge and braintrust is not present and it should be in anyone trying to speak bball outside of a corporate coded realm. You are missing that and I have to explain that. When if you are adept at bball convos. Then you would have never spoke on it.

You have a disconnect to the GAME OF BASKETBALL. Where I know and am indepthly talking about the full game of basketball. As it goes from just the actual idea of the game and into the variables of play from race, parochial/public, skill, outsider art/organized etc.

You are just talking about sports players with no real indepth knowledge about the full game of basketball. It is a game there beyond the game. That if we talking basketball you should know.

You have the disconnect and i pointed it out and how you can dissolve those points of disconnect as well.


I.AM.PIFF said:
I'll be 29 in a few months. Too young maybe but we have enough access to tapes, games, articles and whatnot to make a fair judgment :ld:

with this said,...
I will take this as the completely obvious explanation as to your disconnect. At least you admit this in some way.


I.AM.PIFF said:
Are you saying both Dr.J & Nique are better 1-on-1 players? I'd more than happily agree but basketball is a 5-on-5 sport and I'd value Bird's contributions over them, especially when it comes to passing and shooting the ball (and other intangibles :mjpls: )




Bird did have his fair share of playoff duds (especially in his early career), but so did Nique who only got past the 1st round 3 times in his career and never went beyond the 2nd round.



Ignoring Bird for a second, yall taking these 2 over Bron? :dahellbill: or even Durant?



Really now?



I don't have Bird as a GOAT, at best I have him as a lower end top 10 player.




Yes, there is no way some of those players like Sharman or Bing (among others) should've been there above him.




Am I bugging or do you have him as the 3rd greatest player ever? :dahell:


ALL the later information you asked me about in your reply is from your lack of knowledge on the source material.
Plus a self admitted you don't have the brain trust to draw from. Nor have you ramped because you never said you have access like you did it. You said in this day and age we have access. So you told on yourself there as well.
The problems with things now are people who have disconnect and no way to gain knowledge to be prescient about what they missed being given the reigns to the carriage and don't know horses or buggies. Just like rap, where the consumer is made to perpetuate this disconnect unknowingly. Except in bball we see the reporters and know they don't know wtf they were talembout either. outside of scoop Jackson as analyst. So I already know the disconnect in definitely hoops and hiphop. It is on full display here, unknowingly to even a good poster because of age. What I am saying is go back and look at the shyt from the start and compare. I lived it but i urge you and everyone to go relive because the mediums gateway wise to get you there. Are never going to fill in the real blanks.

The blank is,....
In history nique is not credited because of racism and the misappropriated goat title from bill Russell. That the Boston media given that time.
felt was never going to be defeated, nor shown up from a skillplayer level. When in reality. Anyone watching basketball knows the deck stacked against any team to beat the Celts. Plus what that entails wholeheartedly in THE GAME OF organized play in BASKETBALL.

In that is why nique is not given his just due.

It is why hordes of great ball players are left out.
when they should be discussed. Including creating a large horde of models of success to be successful from.

It is a complete disservice, to skill players in bball. Not to mention one of the all time best skill players in nique.

Like when did someone in the NBA get better than nique in that era before injury. Let alone the idiot front office ruined it and also created why nique was injured because they would not staff the team properly. Which lead to him being injured and took him out of the pocket of media realm discussion and his real time stature as a player.

You guys underestimate the power of what mike did because you never saw it beforehand to have a frame of reference. Plus things are drastically different as far as telling the entire truth because of capitalism. Where even in that Jordan pushed things so far ahead admin wise in everything image related period as far as gaining a profit based return in any and everything. That nique should not get looked over but is dishearteningly left out. Yet in that nique should be blessed with his legacy being given it actual real proper weight.


Art Barr


To summarize for dummies needing cliffs.
You nikkaz did not even respect bird.
till I put that respect singlehandidly on his name here. Yet you not about to try to circumvent what I presented with bird.
to downplay the better actual player in nique.

Don't try to take my words and make it into some white boi myth disproportionate to the real.
nikkaz tweak'n on that.


Art Barr
 

ISO

Pass me the rock nikka
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Messages
63,023
Reputation
9,056
Daps
200,426
Reppin
BX, NYC
It’s funny seeing the same people who downplay rings now saying Nique can’t be better than Bird, Bron, and KD

Before nique got injured his numbers were comparable and he didn’t play with the same level of support
No, they weren’t. Unless you only look at volume scoring and don’t factor in defense and every other aspect of the game. Stfu.
 

ISO

Pass me the rock nikka
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Messages
63,023
Reputation
9,056
Daps
200,426
Reppin
BX, NYC
Just stop breh.
The best player before mike was nique. You know damn well you ain't see that shyt at all.
Said no one ever

Stop mentioning Jordan :snoop:

They thought so highly of Nique they completely omitted him off the top 50 players of All-Time list
 

I.AM.PIFF

You're minor, we're major
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
13,139
Reputation
11,710
Daps
40,791
@Art Barr

What makes Nique "the actual best all time advanced skill player at the three" (your own words) ?

I'm genuinely curious to hear your explanation.
 

ProlificLurker

Superstar
Joined
Aug 9, 2017
Messages
3,935
Reputation
6,389
Daps
16,713
Reppin
NYC/Ayiti
:dead:
fam, go back and look at their career accomplishments, stats, and even playin style.
they play nothin alike
people make that comparison strictly due to body type:deadrose:

glenn robinson isnt comparable to melo

melo and nique is a very respectable discussion. they have identical stats.
same scoring avg,
both have a scoring title
,melo has 10 allstar appearances, dom has 9,
dom has 7 all nba appearances, melo has 6
i mean got damn, both of them were drafted third in the draft:russ:

wilkens, just like melo, didnt have the super teams like bird magic isiah and therefore didnt win any rings. difference is, back then players were respected for their talent, ring or no ring.
nowadays its a joke

Well statwise, there are some similarities. Both are/were high volume one dimensional offensive players, both averaged 20+ points per year, both bucket getters. Both rebound(ed) well for their respective positions, neither are/were particularly fond of passing the ball and neither are/were particularly good defenders. Its more than just similar body type. They're comparable.

Another guy that kinda reminds me of Melo is Mark Aguirre. Championship aside, their yearly #s are fairly similar
 
Last edited:

Art Barr

INVADING SOHH CHAMPION
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
72,060
Reputation
15,088
Daps
100,297
Reppin
CHICAGO
That argument that we're too young to rate Nique holds no weight. There are millions of people out there who watched Nique in his prime and NONE of them have him over Lebron, Kobe, Durant, Bird etc.


Who is dey, nikka.

Looks at username.

Just being a laker fan.
You should know this info.

Yet i am gonna in general expose the headfake the new lakeset has because of disconnect from the bird/magic arena rather easily.



I promise you,...
No nikka from my era who know hoops for real.
Will not slight nique for no fukk'n bron or kd.

Two nikkaz who are not master skill players at their natural positions.
Plus have been moved around on roster because physiologically to skill dispersal there is a gap there. Meaning Durant will get thrown around at the four for real in the real eras. Where he would be what pj made him when he debuted as a two. Bron is only a three because he does not have the IQ to really be a one and if he did. He would have exercised a nightly mismatch every night at the one on a level that exceeded magic from jump but he did not.
Plus he would have won the finals he participated in. As the magic Johnson msu big pg theory. would have easily shown him victory against the spurs and of course the former Celts Carlisle to big three. Plus, he would have known to never trade away a Thompson meets worth type for a suped up white bench warmer, Kurt rambis type. who never converted in college and he played with Westbrook. Plus the fact, he would have used the magic braintrust to succeed immediately like magic did under duress from a rook to an electronic device on his leg suffering from HIV and doing everything in human will based power.
To beat the oversized frontcourt meets oversized post big version.
of what the team of doom was in his day in portland


If bron mastered his natural but he shirk'd to play the three.
So, I can't say bron converting to the three is better than nique. When I seen nique fail against much better with much less.
Plus not have the ball in his hands like lebron playing the one or the three.

Also,....
There is a complete skill gap disparity between mj to kd and bron.

That in that nique is only below mike because he was not able to will or galvanize an inferior unit like Jordan did despite the odds.

That is the only thing separating the two. Outside of that both were one a and one b in the league as the best players.
The whole try to make nique into a dunker is a complete misnomer on whom he was as an actualized skill player.
Nique was one of the best skill players ever in history.
Only player from the era I can say rivals him after Jordan was Richmond as a skill player. As the next fully dominant skill player. Other than that, nique historically after Jordan is damn near the next guy if you saw the shyt for real.
Only people I say better after Jordan over nique is :

Dr j
Connie Hawkins

The players who you can say better is all counter Intuitive from the bird misappropriated goat argument. Which is based on pre to current civil rights era russell's dominance misappropriated from and for the bird argument. Which is completely a racist mechanism of the boston eastern seaboard blue blood media.

The whole slight to nique historically extends from this.

To not know it and try to talk basketball,...means you do not know basketball.


Art Barr

You talk coded about the goat argument.
Simply cause you don't know wtf is the goat argument for real and where it really comes from.

That is the real discussion globally on display here and in bball think tanks. The misappropriated racism that is gon awry and wiped over. Just because Jordan beat the argument. Yet if there was no Jordan and magic would have been thwarted. You nikkaz would know this instead of being shielded from it.



Art Barr
 

Art Barr

INVADING SOHH CHAMPION
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
72,060
Reputation
15,088
Daps
100,297
Reppin
CHICAGO
I see it the opposite :manny:

There would be many stans because of his finishing ability and they would say that "nique needs more help" :skip:


This.

The internet era is not even aware of whom, nique is.

All they know is this fake misappropriated corporate coded talk about everything.
From music to cartoons, movies, social, etc.

They been kept from the good shyt to market mediocrity.
They been kept from shyt they don't even know they would like.

You would think with the net being the net it would change it.

Yet I know better because I watched the real ideals of the internet be swept away for large corporations.
Who hated the internet and right now are nowhere near what they should be if they really knew it for real.




Art Barr
 

SunZoo

The Legendary Super Sapien.
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
36,566
Reputation
13,946
Daps
140,848
Reppin
T.L.C.
I wanna say Melo but it just doesn't feel right :laugh:

That's my guy.

:mjcry:
 
Top