Meh.. Eli is who he is.. Peyton is who he is.. One had a good to great O line most of his career.. The other had a decent to subpar O line most of his career.. One had a solid to good to great defense.. The other had a murky to questionable defense during his career.. One played with a HOF WR or two and a HOF RB.. The other had questionable offensive weapons.. One was hella shook and looked disturbed playing the Patriots.. The other played like his bumbling fool looking self and won both big games against the Patriots.. Eli and Peyton are both good to great in their own right..