MMLP or Eminem Show!

[The_Dread_Dormammu]

Nostalgia pulls me towards the LP but damn did he go ham on TES…

I’m honestly a fan of most of the songs on both but again, The Marshall Mathers LP was, IMO, a huge step up from SSLP…

Kill you
Stan
The way I am
Drug ballad
Remember me
bytch please 2 (not as good as the original but it’s a favorite of mine)


But then you have…

Business
Square Dance
Soldier
Sing For The Moment
Til I Collapse
Superman

Relapse is up there for me too but y’all ain’t ready for that one yet

 

[iliketurtles]

TES classic

 

[Mr. Negative]

MMLP personally.

Objectively, TES had anthems all over it. I really didn't care for it, though.

 

[JQ Legend]

MMLP legit a top 10 maybe top 5 album of all time for me

MMLP could be the GOAT album far as display of technical skill/lyricism

TES classic too tho but MMLP for me

If he woulda took Drug Ballad off, it woulda legit been a flawless album

 

[TL15]

No wrong answer, this is definitely the peak of his career lyrically, commercially, and impact wise.

I go off of what album I would have to get rid of if I had to and I’d get rid of TES so MMLP is the one that I’d choose

 

[Playaz Eyez]

It’s Eminem Show, but either way, this was his peak, and he hasn’t come close.

 

[Artificial Intelligence]

Tes

 

[mundL]

His best year was 2002 cuz of TES and 8 Mile

But comparing these 2 I gotta go with MMLP

He was pissed the fukk off on that Album and I can hardly name a more pissed off album (maybe straight outta compton or so)

TES he was lyricallly sharp and he had this crazy im #1 worldwide attitude which I love but still my vote goes to MMLP

 

[Cuban Pete]

MMLP for me

If they took out Drug Ballad and added Still Dont Give A fukk from SSLP (it fits better on the 2nd album) Id give it 5 mics

 

[Sccit]

I THINK BOTH MMLP AND SSLP > EMINEM SHOW TBH

ALL 3 IS CLASSIX THO

 

[Mac Ten]

MMLP for me….

Album had a bunch of cartoonish moments. I can’t play The Real Slim
shady like that though

 

[InGodWeTrust]

TES

 

[Love Sosa]

Yall don’t fukk w drug ballad

 

[TheMailMan]

TES and relapse are the only 2 albums that I really still listen too.

 

[papa pimp]

mmlp more creative/off kilter and tes more polished

i like music thats rough around the edges so mmlp