More iconic Lakers player: Kobe Bryant or Magic Johnson?
- Thread starter bucks3115
- Start date
Obviously Kobe to everyone under the age of 40 years old.
Everyone over that its probably a toss-up.
Both gave the Lakers 5 rings so its a legit debate.
Everyone over that its probably a toss-up.
Both gave the Lakers 5 rings so its a legit debate.
Ukbrotha
Superstar
Its a tough one. Showtime Lakers though. 
Magic just had too much fun on the court. Just a joy to watch.
But Kobe's highlights as a player is probably only beaten by Mike all time. So its a tough one. I think Kobe edges it.
Magic just had too much fun on the court. Just a joy to watch.
But Kobe's highlights as a player is probably only beaten by Mike all time. So its a tough one. I think Kobe edges it.
Last edited:
It’s definitely a tough one. It depends a lot on your age and the generation you most identify with. Also since their styles of play and personalities are so distinctively different it’s easy for individuals to make a choice on what they prefer.
Ruby'sRevolver
Man in the Black Hat
To me, It's Magic, though I'm sure the Coli will vote for Kobe.
WhoShotCha
Superstar
I think all the factors said previously are relevant. But I think Kobe gets it because his tenure with the Lakeshow is just so much longer. 4 generations damn near saw Kobe wear that purple and gold.
It's crazy the amount of iconic players that franchise has. Dudes like James Worthy third teir and he would be most franchise's best player ever.
EDIT: Actually watched the video posted in the OP and I have to agree with RJ. I didn't think about it that way. I think Kobe is the more iconic Laker, but I think Magic is the more important player
It's crazy the amount of iconic players that franchise has. Dudes like James Worthy third teir and he would be most franchise's best player ever.
EDIT: Actually watched the video posted in the OP and I have to agree with RJ. I didn't think about it that way. I think Kobe is the more iconic Laker, but I think Magic is the more important player
Last edited:
YoungMoneyCashMoneyBoy
Superstar
Come on, man. There is no laker mystique without Magic. They were damn near buffalo bills status with west and baylor. Magic brought them to a new level.
B1G_controversy
Superstar
Magic revolutionized the PG position
But Kobe was a complete player.
We all know how iconic Magic is but I don't think he would've played 17-18 yrs, let alone 20. And Kobe was a warrior on the court, playing through all types of ailments. Add to that Kobe faced better competition in the West than Magic w/ less talented teammates than Magic. What Kobe accomplished in the 20 yrs in LA, really 16 (Dell Harris screwed him as a rook & he was never the same after the Achilles), he's one of the most talked about players, even in retirement
But Kobe was a complete player.
We all know how iconic Magic is but I don't think he would've played 17-18 yrs, let alone 20. And Kobe was a warrior on the court, playing through all types of ailments. Add to that Kobe faced better competition in the West than Magic w/ less talented teammates than Magic. What Kobe accomplished in the 20 yrs in LA, really 16 (Dell Harris screwed him as a rook & he was never the same after the Achilles), he's one of the most talked about players, even in retirement
Come on, man. There is no laker mystique without Magic. They were damn near buffalo bills status with west and baylor. Magic brought them to a new level.
So the Bills had the first dynasty in league history, the first big superstar in league history, and championships in damn near every decade?
fukk outta here, Lakers went from a great franchise to the GOAT franchise within Magic and Kobe’s tenures.
Magic
johnedwarduado
Banned
Compare the greatest PG in nba history to a selfish SG who has the record for most Fg missed shot brehs
BigTyme Records
Superstar
Magic