Even the biggest Love skeptic would concede his prowess as a scorer and rebounder -- right before bringing up the defensive end. Here's the thing: It's hard to find statistical support for the widespread notion that Love is a defensive turnstile.
It's possible to highlight stats that showcase Love's defensive shortcomings, particularly as a rim protector. New
SportVU player-tracking data on NBA.com showed that last season opponents shot 57.4 percent when Love was within five feet of attempts near the rim, the league's fourth-worst rate among players who defended at least five rim attempts per game.
However, opponent shooting percentage tells only half of the story. Love's reluctance to contest shots also kept him out of foul trouble and opponents off the free throw line. His 1.8 fouls per 36 minutes were the fewest of any regular big man last season (no one else was below 2.0 per 36), and not coincidentally, the Timberwolves allowed the league's lowest rate of free throws per field goal attempt. The trade-off between not fouling and surrendering layups didn't always work out for Minnesota and former coach Rick Adelman
encouraged his team to foul more frequently, but looking at opponent shooting percentages without context is unfair to Love.
There's also the matter of rebounding. For individual players, defensive rebounding is not as valuable as offensive rebounding because many defensive rebounds are discretionary -- another defender will get the rebound if one individual does not -- but it's still part of defense, and the Timberwolves have had a better defensive rebound percentage with Love on the court every season of his career. Last season, per NBA.com/Stats, they rebounded 75.3 percent of opponents' misses with Love and 72.4 percent when he was on the bench.
Add it up and ESPN's real plus-minus shows Love as an above-average defensive player,
even for a big man. (Post players rate better on defense in plus-minus metrics as compared to perimeter players.) And despite playing Love with another poor rim protector in center
Nikola Pekovic, Minnesota was average defensively last season.
As
Zach Lowe has described at length in the past, the problems for Love and the Wolves occur primarily because Corey Brewer and Kevin Martin are "serial gamblers". From Lowe's article in March:
Corey Brewer and Kevin Martin, two key wing free agents, gamble their way into crazy fouls all over the floor...These guys are serial gamblers, and a lot of their crunch-time fouls happen before Minnesota’s opponent is in the bonus. But those fouls also put opponents in the bonus.
• Quick opposing point guards can puncture Minnesota’s scheme. The Wolves play a conservative pick-and-roll defense in which Love and Pekovic hang near the paint to corral ball handlers instead of chasing them far from the hoop. It works in the aggregate; neither big is a major plus defender, but they both understand the scheme and approach it with solid footwork.
And really, "serial gambler" is a generous way to describe what Martin is defensively; long before any Kevin Love trade talks heated up,
Kawakami described Martin as "...a horrendous, horrendous defensive player, who doesn't fight through picks and often zones out off the ball, leading to more than a few wide open shots when his man cuts to the basket or across the floor."
That porous perimeter defense helps to explain why opponents shot so well at the rim - yes, the Wolves give up a high percentage, but Love and Pekovic are also a) put in that situation more often and b) whether they weren't fouling by design or as a tactic to stay on the floor, they were
one of the 20 least foul prone teams in NBA history. Put in simplest terms, playing the Wolves was like getting free runs at the basket if you had capable perimeter players. And that didn't favor either Love or Pekovic, who neither operate well in space nor protecting the rim.
So as a quirky by-product of that system alluded to by Pelton and borne out by the numbers, even the Wolves' opponent field goal percentage overall is a little overstated: they managed to limit the number of points surrendered by allowing
the fewest opponent free throw attempts in the league last season despite
playing at the fourth-highest pace in the league.