My Brehs, Let's Rate The DC Animated Joints

[Swiggy]

With the latest drop of Flashpoint Paradox and its undeniable piffness, I think we should all take a moment and figure out not where we rank the DC animated movies. Instead of putting them in descending order, just use the 5 star rating system.

Here they are in order of release:

Superman: Doomsday - 1 star
Justice League: The New Frontier - 3 star
Batman: Gotham Knight - 3 star
Wonder Woman - 4 star
Green Lantern: First Flight - 3 star
Superman/Batman: Public Enemies - 2 star
Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths - 5 star
Batman: Under the Red Hood - 5 star
Superman/Batman: Apocalypse - 5 star
All-Star Superman - 4 Star
Green Lantern: Emerald Knights - 3
Batman: Year One - 3
Justice League: Doom - 4
Superman vs. The Elite - 4
Batman: The Dark Knight Returns - 5
Superman: Unbound - 3
Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox - 5

I don't even own any of the 3 star or under joints on my list, but that's how I see them. If I had to choose a favorite three: Under the Red Hood, The Dark Knight Returns, and Crises on Two Earths. Flashpoint Paradox just came through and crushed buildings, but CoTE been a favorite of mine for a minute, and to me, ain't NOTHING gonna knock off TDKR or UTRH. So in the long run, TFP might break top 3.

And there's only more to come

 

[k5banga]

new frontier was actually good bruh, Superman Doomsday was really a big let down

 

[R=G]

Superman: Doomsday - 1 star
Justice League: The New Frontier - 3 star
Batman: Gotham Knight - 3 star
Wonder Woman - 4 star
Green Lantern: First Flight - 3 star
Superman/Batman: Public Enemies - 2 star
Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths - 5 star
Batman: Under the Red Hood - 5 star
Superman/Batman: Apocalypse - 5 star
All-Star Superman - 4 Star
Green Lantern: Emerald Knights - 3
Batman: Year One - 3
Justice League: Doom - 4
Superman vs. The Elite - 4
Batman: The Dark Knight Returns - 5
Superman: Unbound - 3
Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox - 5

You left out Mask of the Phantasm, the Batwomen one, and Batman/Mr. Freeze..Mask of the Phantasm was the best out of the early ones though, bar none. I fell in love with that movie and always wondered if Phantasm would show up on the show. I still got the big ass VHS tape box of that shyt..lol

Out of the whole thing though? The Batman and Justice League ones are the best....Wonder Woman was pretty damn good too.

 

[Ain't That Something]

Batman beyond return of joker was another good one breh.

 

[Grifter]

I'd give Doomsday 2 stars just cause of the fight/death scene.

 

[Real]

I can watch Under the Red Hood at anytime.

 

[Just like bruddas]

Superman: Doomsday - 1.5 star
Justice League: The New Frontier - 2.6 star
Batman: Gotham Knight - 5 star
Wonder Woman - havent seen it yet
Green Lantern: First Flight - 3 star
Superman/Batman: Public Enemies - 3 star
Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths - 5 star
Batman: Under the Red Hood - 5 star
Superman/Batman: Apocalypse - 5 star
All-Star Superman - 3.8 Star
Green Lantern: Emerald Knights - 4.1
Batman: Year One - 3.7
Justice League: Doom - 3.4
Superman vs. The Elite - 2
Batman: The Dark Knight Returns - 5
Superman: Unbound - 4
Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox - 3.2

 

[kingdarius]

im just gon copy and paste OPs with my star rankings

Superman: Doomsday - 3 star
Justice League: The New Frontier - 2 star
Batman: Gotham Knight - 2 star
Wonder Woman - 5 star
Green Lantern: First Flight - 2 star
Superman/Batman: Public Enemies - 3 star
Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths - 5 star
Batman: Under the Red Hood - 5 star
Superman/Batman: Apocalypse - 5 star
All-Star Superman - 3 Star
Green Lantern: Emerald Knights - 2
Batman: Year One - 3
Justice League: Doom - 4
Superman vs. The Elite - 3
Batman: The Dark Knight Returns - 5
Superman: Unbound - 2
Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox - 5

 

[Ghostface Trillah]

Doom is the goat just off of batman telling the justice league they're all fools at the end then telling superman the plan to stop him if he goes evil is THE WHOLE JUSTICE LEAGUE then bouncing on them.

That's my batman

A justice league movie of batman going rogue would be

 

[-DMP-]

Thanks for this thread, really need it since I'm behind and just now starting to watch these.

of those listed ive seen.

Batman Year One -3.5
Flash Point-5
Dark Knight Returns-5
Red Hood-4
Gotham Knight-3

What else would you guys recommend?

-DMP-

 

[Ill Lou Malnati]

There's been so goddam many I can't even keep it all straight...

Superman: Doomsday - 2 stars
Justice League: The New Frontier - 3 stars
Batman: Gotham Knight - The anime one? Never seen it. Don't want to.
Wonder Woman - 3 star
Green Lantern: First Flight - 3 stars
Superman/Batman: Public Enemies - 2 star
Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths - 4 star
Batman: Under the Red Hood - 3 stars
Superman/Batman: Apocalypse - 3 star
All-Star Superman - 1 Star on Grant Morrison
Green Lantern: Emerald Knights - 4 stars
Batman: Year One - 3 stars
Justice League: Doom - 4 stars
Superman vs. The Elite - 2 stars
Batman: The Dark Knight Returns - Haven't seen it yet.
Superman: Unbound - 3 stars
Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox - Need to check this one out...

Old school DCAU shyt:
Batman: Mask of the Phantasm - 4 stars
Batman: Mystery of the Batwoman - 2 stars
Batman/Mr. Freeze: SubZero - 3 stars
Batmany Beyond: Return of the Joker - 3 stars
The Batman vs. Dracula - 3 stars

 

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

Superman: Doomsday - B
Justice League: The New Frontier - B-
Batman: Gotham Knight - B
Wonder Woman - B
Green Lantern: First Flight - C+
Superman/Batman: Public Enemies - A-
Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths - B-
Batman: Under the Red Hood - A+
Superman/Batman: Apocalypse - A+
All-Star Superman - A-
Green Lantern: Emerald Knights - N/A
Batman: Year One - A+
Justice League: Doom - A-
Superman vs. The Elite - B+
Batman: The Dark Knight Returns - A
Superman: Unbound - B-
Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox - n/a

Superman/Shazam: Return of Black Adam + 2 other shorts - A-

 

[Brandsdale]

With the latest drop of Flashpoint Paradox and its undeniable piffness, I think we should all take a moment and figure out not where we rank the DC animated movies. Instead of putting them in descending order, just use the 5 star rating system.

Here they are in order of release:

Superman: Doomsday - 1 star
Justice League: The New Frontier - 3 star
Batman: Gotham Knight - 3 star
Wonder Woman - 4 star
Green Lantern: First Flight - 3 star
Superman/Batman: Public Enemies - 2 star
Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths - 5 star
Batman: Under the Red Hood - 5 star
Superman/Batman: Apocalypse - 5 star
All-Star Superman - 4 Star
Green Lantern: Emerald Knights - 3
Batman: Year One - 3
Justice League: Doom - 4
Superman vs. The Elite - 4
Batman: The Dark Knight Returns - 5
Superman: Unbound - 3
Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox - 5

I don't even own any of the 3 star or under joints on my list, but that's how I see them. If I had to choose a favorite three: Under the Red Hood, The Dark Knight Returns, and Crises on Two Earths. Flashpoint Paradox just came through and crushed buildings, but CoTE been a favorite of mine for a minute, and to me, ain't NOTHING gonna knock off TDKR or UTRH. So in the long run, TFP might break top 3.

And there's only more to come

watched both on Netflix. PIFF

 

[Bruce Wayne]

DC's Animated Movies are almost as Great as Marvel's Big Screen Movies when they really put their Heart into it. Detective does Hold a better chance %70 of the time at telling a Piff Story of their Characters than Marvel does. Watching Phantasm when you're Fresh off of The Animated Series is the way to do it and Batwoman was an Overlooked Goodie too. Year One & Red Hood definitely made it Possible to show off that Gritty Batman that most People aren't really used to, same with The TDKReturns Movies. I wish DC would put the Story of Knightfall on their List of Animation Stories to tell too. that they haven't yet but there is so much to do with Batman.

The Justice League Movies are Likable, my Favorite will always be Apocalypse and Crisis On 2 Earths had me with Owlman on Screen. He's definitely a Dope Ass Villian, hated the shyt out of almost All of Doom though.

I'll have to take some more of those Titles down because I haven't watched everything on that List. No Green Arrow Piff thought? Oliver is my Dude.

 

[Wcthesecret]

...wonder what the teen titans the judas contract animated film would've been like if it had been made?