Trust me its not you bruh, POF has become the
ATTENTION WHORE website. I used to get at least 3 messages a week without having to do any work. Now Just like you if i send out 10 messages i might get 1 or 2 replys. The women on that site aren't serious about nothin they more than likely already got boyfriends and are just looking for somebody to message them and bother them to fill there own ego. I have smashed A LOT of girls from pof, prolly 10-15 just last year. I don't think i hit one bytch from POF this year.
My suggestion is use
Tagged, Mocospace, and Skout, those are providing all the pu**y i could want these days.