My Top 10 Players in NBA History

Sauce Dab

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Feb 28, 2015
Messages
48,481
Reputation
16,319
Daps
253,903
Dirk never played any defense. Sure David Robinson was undressed by Hakeem Olajuwon, but that's the greatest center in NBA history. Hakeem also made Shaq look silly in the playoffs.

David Robinson was an elite offensive and defensive player. He could do everything on the court. And at a high level. He could honestly be even HIGHER on the list. He just lacked the elite killer instinct to fully maximize his physical attributes. In terms of pure physical talent, he would probably be top 3 all-time alongside Shaq and LeBron.

Scottie Pippen is the greatest perimeter defender in NBA history while being a masterful floor general as a point forward with an elite post-game. Pippen might be the most underrated player in NBA history. He was absolutely phenomenal at his peak.
What kind of defense were McGrady and Durant playing? Durant is good now but it took years of work. Put Dirk out there on the playground and he's gone light it up.
 
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
39,600
Reputation
-17,891
Daps
84,301
Reppin
NULL
What kind of defense were McGrady and Durant playing? Durant is good now but it took years of work. Put Dirk out there on the playground and he's gone light it up.

You must be a young kid. When T-Mac was in Toronto playing with Vince Carter, he was mostly known for his ELITE defense. The fact he turned into a scoring champion at Orlando turned out to be a surprise.

Its hard to play elite defense all the time when your team counts on you to score 30 points per game. The only players in NBA history to do that while playing elite defense is Kobe and Jordan.

However, when they needed to, T-Mac and Durant were ELITE defenders. Durant now is playing elite defense cause he got other guys on the Warriors to carry the scoring load. And T-Mac did the same when he was in Toronto playing second fiddle to Vince Carter.
 
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
39,600
Reputation
-17,891
Daps
84,301
Reppin
NULL
Every player in my Top 10 list were ELITE both offensively and defensively. They were also ELITE athletes with ELITE size and length for their position.

You can't be one of the 10 best players in NBA history and not be FREAKISH in every way.

That's why ya'll need to stop mentioning names like Magic, Bird, and Dirk. Those guys were not freakish athletes. And they had serious flaws when it came to defense. Just because they won championships or have had media hyping them as all-time great don't make them so.
 

god shamgod

Veteran
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
38,089
Reputation
6,644
Daps
113,615
I’m convinced you cats never watched pippen play they way he gets overrated by revisionists

On no planet is pippen better than bird or kd. If you aren’t at least in your mid to upper 30’s you shouldn’t even be commenting on Jordan’s era those edited you tube videos aren’t receipts either
 

MJ Truth

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Feb 1, 2015
Messages
39,340
Reputation
3,929
Daps
156,337
That's the purest way of judging whose the best. Just because someone has more success cause they got paired with a better coach (like Tim Duncan) or had incredible health for a long time (like Kareem Abdul-Jabbar) don't make them the best. To me, being the best is the guy who I am willing to put my life on the line for to win 1 basketball game. That's the purest way of judging who is better than who.

And based on that standard, T-Mac, Pippen, and KG are definitely in everyone's top 25. And in my top 10, they're definitely up there.

In terms of skill, talent, and athleticism, you can't find 10 better than McGrady, Pippen, and Garnett.
You would take Pippen and T Mac and Garnett with your life on the line and not KAJ or Duncan? :dwillhuh:
 

chowism

King of Short Gang
Joined
Nov 21, 2016
Messages
5,828
Reputation
-890
Daps
25,679
Not even mad at your list. I don't agree with alot on there but putting respect on T Mac name:salute:
 
Top