Name a nostalgia match that would sell, no matter how potentially terrible...

[Alexander The Great]

so many of the matches mentioned had the potential to be done when all these guys were still either active or in much better shape

 

[TransJenner]

Undertaker and Sting
If booked right

 

[Nintendough]

Rock vs HBK is wrestling apocalypse. This site would crash.

Both of them are still in shape enough to still do it.

 

[Black Andy Dwyer]

I definitely agree with HBK vs Rock. Sucks we never really got that during their primes. Shawn left right as the Rock was becoming a star and he came back around the time the Rock was leaving for Hollywood

I would actually be down for a Rock vs Undertaker match at Wrestlemania. Those two only went head to head at PPV's a handful of times from what I can remember.

 

[Kill Dat Noize]

could you imagine if bret and shawn were still in WWF when rock and austin got hot?

 

[El Guapo]

Since Rikishi ruined the Survivor Series 1999 main event we never got the Triple H vs. The Rock vs. Stone Cold triple threat.

17+ years in the making

 

[Norrin Radd]

Rock vs Taker

 

[clutchington]

Stone Cold vs The Rock Part 4, WrestleMania 2018. Part 2 will forever be the greatest WrestleMania main event in history, and no one can tell me otherwise. However, greatest WrestleMania MATCH of all time is HBK vs. Taker Part 1 at WrestleMania 25. But we don't need a part 3 of that.

 

[Kid Kash]

RVD vs Jerry Lynn

 

[King Ka$h]

I'm going to go a little out there and say Charlotte vs Trish (the nostalgia coming from Trish's side obviously)-The WWE loves to push the narrative that Trish is one of the greatest,if not THE greatest female wrestlers of all time,and they're really trying to build Charlotte into the next big thing.

...This might not be appropriate to the thread but it's all I got

 

[Francis White]

AJ vs lita
Broken Matt and brother Nero vs the Wyatt family
Hogan vs CM Punk

 

[Momentum]

Hogan vs AJ Styles

Neckbeards would chant "this is awesome" for an hour before they even locked up.

 

[El Cocodrilo]

Hogan vs AJ Styles

Neckbeards would chant "this is awesome" for an hour before they even locked up.

And Hogan would go over even though he can't even run or do the legdrop anymore

 

[luckyse7enz]

Undertaker vs Sting is the defintion of this thread


But to be realistic since Sting is retired....I would like to see HBK vs Rock

Both seem like they can go for one last WM moment

Where's this idea that HBK isn't realistically retired coming from when he hung it up over half a decade before Sting did?

 

[Momentum]

And Hogan would go over even though he can't even run or do the legdrop anymore

@Hollywood Hogan