Athletes (not just physically) that I’ve consistently/exclusively (my teams) watched regarding talent+winning. LT is the best but I didn’t really watch him. Wayne Gretzky is also up there but I didn’t watch Hockey like that plus he didn’t play for the Rangers for too long.
1) Derek Jeter/Mariano
2) Patrick Ewing
3) Michael Strahan
4) Eli Manning
5) Tiki Barber
6) Hakeem Nicks
7) Carmelo Anthony
8) Henrik lunquist (don’t really watch Hockey)
9) CC Sabathia/Alex Rodriguez
10)Justin Tuck/Ahmad Bradshaw
11) lol, has to be Kenny P. Loved his game like how others love Sean Taylor.
12) Plaxico Burress, lol. Top 12
This is straight off the top. Not really into lists because each player/team/time is unique and hard to judge but... The current Yankee team also has some talent. Roger Clemens was also a Beast. Played for too many teams but he def deserves credit. Kenny Phillips (And a bit of JPP) is also a player I LOVED watching. Sucks he got injured.