The best tracks on the album IMO:
Writers
Madman
Sons
Your Story, My Story
Nasty Esco Nasir
Shine Together
Pause Tapes
It’s Time
GiT Ready
3rd Childhood
I agree with this 100%. I prefer albums to be short so 10-12 songs max. Junkie is the only song I wasn't feeling at all. Even conceptually that song didn't feel fully fleshed out.
I don't feel like this is Nas at his best. It's not Premier at his best. That's okay because I'm wasn't expecting that at their age. If they did this album in 1998-2002 it would be far superior. I'm still happy with it and on first listen it's 4/5. I said it wouldn't surpass the De La album and it didn't. Cabin in the Sky is still album of the year to me. Pos is still lyricist of the year.
With Nas I don't feel like he has those poetic/stream of consciousness verses like It Ain't Hard to Tell, Verbal Intercourse, or Take it in Blood in him anymore. I've felt that way for years not just now which is why there's other rappers I listen to way more than Nas now. He doesn't do the detailed story telling like Shootouts. He's a lot more direct now. You can see that in New York State of Mind 3. It's nowhere near as descriptive as 1 & 2. I wish he would've pushed himself to get back to that. He kind of makes up for those flaws by leaning into concepts. That kept me engaged especially on Writers. Loved that he shouted out Sane and Smith whose tags I used to see all over my neighborhood when I was a kid.
Premier surprised me in that there aren't a lot of stereotypical sounding Premier beats on here. They sound different. It's not really a good or bad thing because the production is good there's just not that 1 beat that hits like his best stuff. There's no Full Clip or Mass Appeal. Madman was where things started to come together and the beats went on a nice run.
Only 1 listen so I may get into this more but I'm happy they finally gave us something. Should've have happened way sooner though.
If Nas makes another album I want it to be Pete Rock. His work is just more melodic than Premier while still being boom bap and I think that what Nas needs to be at his best. Next would be Q Tip followed by Alchemist.