That argument is silly. Duncan might be the GOAT PF, but if he played center no one would call him the GOAT anything. He wouldn't even be top 4.

what kind of logic is that? If Jordan played center he wouldn't be top 100
That argument is silly. Duncan might be the GOAT PF, but if he played center no one would call him the GOAT anything. He wouldn't even be top 4.

That argument is silly. Duncan might be the GOAT PF, but if he played center no one would call him the GOAT anything. He wouldn't even be top 4.

You are saying Duncan is an automatic top 4 player, because he is the best player at his position all-time. That argument is stupid, because there are other players that played center, point guard, small forward and shooting guard that were better than Duncan. He doesn't get extra credit because of his position.
what kind of logic is that? If Jordan played center he wouldn't be top 100
Hakeem.Shaq, Wilt, Kareem...
![]()

Hakeem.![]()

Why are you bringing up team accomplishments? Was Duncan a better individual player than Hakeem?4 rings/5 Finals appearances >>>> 2 rings 2 Finals appearances![]()
Why are you bringing up team accomplishments? Was Duncan a better individual player than Hakeem?
You are saying Duncan is an automatic top 4 player, because he is the best player at his position all-time. That argument is stupid, because there are other players that played center, point guard, small forward and shooting guard that were better than Duncan. He doesn't get extra credit because of his position.
The other players in the top 10 won just as many rings.Fine, you don't want to give him credit for being the GOAT at this position
but you're going to ignore he brought 4 titles to an organization which had ZERO before he got there? or that he has the individual accolades to rival anyone?
The other players in the top 10 won just as many rings.
His resume while great, doesn't compare to Magic's, Jordan's or Kareem's.