nearly 5 years later.. where do YOU rank american gangster on jay's catalogue

[Grano-Grano]

Reasonable Doubt
The Blueprint
American Gangster




Classics on classics on classics

 

[AAKing23]

top 5

 

[HollywoodP]

One of his classics for sure...top 3 prolly.

 

[Dro_Pesci]

I really like American Gangster but I'm not trying to sit here and arrange his albums n shyt damn

 

[flipn50]

Blueprint
Reasonable Doubt
Vol 1. In My Lifetime
American Gangster - I ranked it number 4
Black Album
Blueprint 2

 

[you're NOT "n!ggas"]

I really like American Gangster but I'm not trying to sit here and arrange his albums n shyt damn

as if i demanded you come in and reply on the thread, but ok

 

[RocPG]

RD
Vol 1 - if u can get past Sunshine and that wack song with Lil Kimmy
Blueprint
American Gangsta
Black Album

Hov has 5 Classics...don't even ask him how!!!!!

 

[Stepdaddy]

Jay's best albums go in order beginning with Reasonable Doubt

 

[Eternal Tecate]

3rd

 

[Gifted one]

6th, Jay has a great catalogue

 

[Kap Kapperson]

Top 4 album but in chronological order:
RD, BP, TBA, AG

AG always seemed like a Reasonable Doubt 2 to me...

 

[ThatsEnough]

shyt was nice

 

[YBE]

Second best IMO

Both RD and AG sound like movies, each track is like an act and there's no corny ass radio singles to fukk up the flow

I remember when it first dropped and Jay wouldn't let them sell it track by track on Itunes at first cause he wanted people to experience the whole thing. I feel like this was the last time he really put his all into a project

exactly.

playing American Gangster cruising down the FDR at night

 

[Bobhoward]

Blueprint
Reasonable Doubt
Black Album
American Gangster
Vol. 2: Hard Knock Life
Vol. 1
The Dynasty
Vol. 3
Kingdom Come
Watch the Throne
Blueprint 2

You really have WTT that low?

Top 5 Jay album to me no question.

Reasonable Doubt, Blueprint, Black Album, American Gangster, Watch the Throne.

Order is debatable and I don't even know how I'd personally rank them.

 

[Ziggiy]

Reasonable Doubt
The Blueprint
The Black Album
American Gangster
Watch The Throne
BP3
Vol.1
Dynasty
Vol.2
Kingdom Come
Vol 3
BP2