NFL all-time Team Team Challenge

[Taadow]

Alright, this will burn a workday. Lol

THE ASSIGNMENT: We have 32 positions and 32 teams.
Make the best team you can with only one team per position. You get all the players that ever played for that team at that position.

For example: of course Deion is the first CB you think of, and he is the preeminent Falcon. But if you choose Falcons for CB,
you can’t choose Falcons for any other position listed. But your saving grace is Deion was also a 49er, Cowboy, Raven, and…Commander -
so you may have a deeper pool of talented teammates with those franchises.

I will give a template for you to fill, and I will drop mine for comparison/fights.

 

[Taadow]

Offense

QB
RB
FB
> 3rd Down RB

TE
WR
WR
> Slot WR

OT
OG
C
OG
OT

Defense ——————-


DT
DT
DE
DE

OLB
MLB
> 3-4 MLB2
OLB

CB
CB
SS
FS
> Nickel DB

Special Teams ———————————-

K
P
ST Coverage
KR
PR

Coaching Staff

 

[broller]

To clarify:

1. OT and OG are considered different positions, therefore different teams must be used?

2. What about safety? Is free different than strong?

3. KR is different than PR in terms of teams?

4. When you get a player from that team, ie. Deion on Baltimore, he's gonna be not that good, correct? You're getting the player in that moment, ie . 2004 Deion?

 

[FTBS]

Doing my best off the top of the head:

Mahomes
Barry
Jerry
Randy
Edelman
Shannon
Munoz
Some nikkas as G and C
Thomas

Reggie
Bruce
Donald
Sapp

Ray
LT
Singletary

Deion
Revis
Rod Woodson
Charles Woodson

Vinateri

Parcells
Walsh
Belichek

 

[BucciMane]

The biggest question is are we taking they player based on their performance on that specific team? If you take Jerry Rice, are we taking his time with the 49er's or can I put him on Seattle with the same value he had when he was with the 49er's? I'm going to assume you're talking about how they performed with the specific franchise?

 

[Taadow]

Offense

QB Colts (Unitas, Peyton, Luck, Captain Comeback, Majik Man, Jeff George)
RB Jaguars (Natrone Means, Fred Taylor, Jones-Drew, Fournette, Etienne - lot of versatility there)
FB Dolphins (Csonka, and the pass-catching of Keith Byars)
> 3rd Down RB Broncos (Terrell Davis, plus Denver has a history of flash-in-the-pan RBs that kick ass for 2 seasons then fade away. Like Clinton, McGahee, Gaston Green, Rod Bernstine, both Andersons, Hillis, chit is crazy!)

TE Patriots (Russ Francis, Marv Cook, Ben Coates, Aaron, Hernandez, Gronk)
WR 49ers (Rice, Taylor, T.O. J.J. Stokes, Isaac Bruce, Crabtree, Deebo)
WR Bengals (Collinsworth, Carl Pickens, Darnay Scott, Peter Warrick, Ochocinco, Houshmanzadeh, Higgins, Chase)
> Slot WR Lions (Megaton, Herman Moore, Brett Perriman, Mel Gray, Johnnie Morton, Amon-Ra)

OT Falcons (Mike Kenn, Bill Fralic, George Kunz, Bob Whitfield, Chris Hinton, Tyson Clabo)
OG Cowboys ( Jon Niland, Nate Newton, Mark Stepnoski, Larry Allen, Flozell Adams, Leonard Davis, Zack Martin, Andre Gurode)
C Oilers/Titans (Bruce Matthews, Bob Schmidt, Mark Stepnoski again, Kevin Mawae, Morgan Cox)
OG Chiefs (Ed Budde, Will Shields, Dave Szott, Brian Waters, Brendan Albert, Joe Thuney, Creed Humphrey, Tre’ Smith)
OT Texans (Tony Boselli, Duane Brown, Ephraim Salaam, Wade Smith)

Defense ——————-


DT Rams (Merlin Olsen, Sean Gilbert, D’Marco Farr, Aaron Donald)
DT Buccaneers (LeRoy Selmon, Warren Sapp, Santana Dotson, Gerald McCoy, Vita Vea)
DE Vikings (Carl Eller, Jim Marshall, John Randle, Chris Doleman, Kevin Williams, Jared Allen, Emerson Griffen, Danielle Hunter)
DE Chargers (Earl Faison, Deacon Jones, Leslie O’Neal, Lee Williams, Shawne Merriman, Melvin Ingram, Joey Bosa)

OLB Steelers, c’mon (Lambert, Ham, Lloyd, Kevin Greene, Jason Gildon, Joey Porter, Farrior, Harrison, T.J. Watt? Slam Dunk)
MLB Bears - another easy one (Butkus, Singletary, Donta Jones, Urlacher)
> 3-4 MLB2 Panthers (Sam Mills, Jon Beason, Kuechly)
OLB Giants (L.T., Carson, Sam Huff, Carl Banks, Jessie Armstead, Zack DeOssie)

CB Raiders (Willie Brown, Lester Hayes, Mike Haynes, Terry McDaniel, Nnamdi, Rod Woodson, Charles Woodson, James Trapp)
CB Jets (Revis Island, James Hasty, Erik McMillan, Aaron Glenn, Ty Law, Aaron Cromartie, Sauce)
SS Ravens (Ed Reed, Bennie Thompson, Kyle Hamilton, Bernard Pollard)
FS Seahawks (Kenny Easley, Eugene Robinson, Daryl Williams, Earl Thomas, Quandre Diggs, Julian Love)
> Nickel DB Cardinals (Larry & Adrian Wilson, Aeneas Williams, P.P., Night Train Lane, Roy Green, Tim McDonald, Chuck Cecil, Terry Hoage, Pat Tillman - R.I.P.)

Special Teams ———————————-

K Saints - Morten Andersen (1 of 2 Ks in HOF), Tom Dempsey (63-yd FG was longest for decades), John Carney (set record streak for most FG without a miss)
P Eagles (Jeff Feagles, Sean Landeta - only team with 2 Top-10 punters)
ST Coverage Bills ( Marty Schottenheimer, Steve Tasker, Ken Davis, Sam Cowart, Mitch Morse, Jairus Byrd, Tre’Davious White, Tremaine Edwards)
KR Browns (Eric Metcalf, Michael Jackson (HEE hee!), Dennis Northcutt, Josh Cribbs)
PR TFKA Washington’s/Commanders ( Darrell Green, Brian Mitchell, Desmond Howard, Deion Sanders, Antwan Randle-El, Desean Jackson)

Coaching Staff Packers (Curly Lambeau, Vince Lombardi, Mike Holmgren + Holmgren Coaching Tree

Mike Holmgren Coaching Tree

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/f/fd/Holmgren_Coaching_Tree.jpg

Am I wrong?

 

[Baka's Weird Case]

Am I wrong?

Looks pretty exhaustive to me

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

The easiest election of all is Barry Sanders as RB because to be frank, no other lions would be worthy to be selected.

EDIT: wait you're selecting position UNITS, not just an individual player as starter?

 

[Taadow]

The biggest question is are we taking they player based on their performance on that specific team? If you take Jerry Rice, are we taking his time with the 49er's or can I put him on Seattle with the same value he had when he was with the 49er's? I'm going to assume you're talking about how they performed with the specific franchise?

We are going off the Honor system LOL.

When we see “WR Seahawks”, our minds are more likely to think Largent, Galloway, Blades, Kearse, Baldwin…that’s not a bad lineup though.

IMO, the hardest part of this is: is Seattle so much better with WR than at any other position all-Time?

 

[Taadow]

The easiest election of all is Barry Sanders as RB because to be frank, no other lions would be worthy to be selected.

EDIT: wait you're selecting position UNITS, not just an individual player as starter?

Yes, position units - the ENTIRETY of the position unit…for EACH and ALL teams…FOR-EV-ER.


FOR.
EV.
ER.

 

[Taadow]

To clarify:

1. OT and OG are considered different positions, therefore different teams must be used?

2. What about safety? Is free different than strong?

3. KR is different than PR in terms of teams?

4. When you get a player from that team, ie. Deion on Baltimore, he's gonna be not that good, correct? You're getting the player in that moment, ie . 2004 Deion?

Very good questions, Sir.

1. Yes. But since you have 2 OGs and 2 OTs in a formation, that allows for 4 (different) team selections.

2. Yes. Free is different from Strong. There is also a Nickelback option that is not striated.

3. Yes. KR is different than PR just like real life. So 2 different team selections.

4. Yes, you get Baltimore Deion - but he wasn’t terrible, right? Therein lies the challenge, my friend!