Normani: “Why Does Pop Have To Be So White?”

Wear My Dawg's Hat

Superstar
Joined
Nov 18, 2016
Messages
3,532
Reputation
1,950
Daps
15,039
Reppin
The Land That Time Forgot
because Beyonce and Rihanna are the immovable objects and unstoppable forces ...

Ask Ciara, Keri Hilson, Tinashe, Ester Dean etc.......

But if your auntie, mother or grandmother still have their vinyl albums or cds, you will find in their collections an extensive variety of female singers: Aretha, Whitney, Chaka Khan/Rufus, Anita Baker, Natalie Cole, Roberta Flack, Janet Jackson, Donna Summer, Cheryl Lynn, Melba Moore, Me"Lisa Morgan, Dianne Reeves, Patti LaBelle, Gladys Knight/Pips, Mariah, Lauryn Hill, Cherrelle.

It would have been unimaginable to previous black generations that just two singers would be dominant
for close to 15 years.

Hell, everyone who appeared on Soul Train had a hit on the radio. 40 episodes a year, two artists on each show meant we saw 80 top SOUL (emphasized for purpose...) artists each year.

That Beyonce and Rihanna are "the last ones standing" is a sign of the slow death of singer-based black music, when compared to the abundant past we once had.
 

CarmelBarbie

At peace
Supporter
Joined
Nov 19, 2016
Messages
10,600
Reputation
8,594
Daps
58,877
Reppin
Charlotte
But if your auntie, mother or grandmother still have their vinyl albums or cds, you will find in their collections an extensive variety of female singers: Aretha, Whitney, Chaka Khan/Rufus, Anita Baker, Natalie Cole, Roberta Flack, Janet Jackson, Donna Summer, Cheryl Lynn, Melba Moore, Me"Lisa Morgan, Dianne Reeves, Patti LaBelle, Gladys Knight/Pips, Mariah, Lauryn Hill, Cherrelle.

It would have been unimaginable to previous black generations that just two singers would be dominant
for close to 15 years.

Hell, everyone who appeared on Soul Train had a hit on the radio. 40 episodes a year, two artists on each show meant we saw 80 top SOUL (emphasized for purpose...) artists each year.

That Beyonce and Rihanna are "the last ones standing" is a sign of the slow death of singer-based black music, when compared to the abundant past we once had.

The examples he gave aren’t talented for the most part. A lot of mediocre artists are being put out there. There’s a big difference between the list you provided and the one he did. One group could actually sing, had talent, and made good music. The other list? Bleh. That’s the only way to describe it. I think with social media, YouTube and whatnot it’s given easier access for people who aren’t very talented to get a Platform.
 

Taadow

The StarchBishop™️
Joined
Sep 4, 2012
Messages
41,751
Reputation
10,416
Daps
104,041
Reppin
Crispness
All her songs sound alike.

That's what's wrong with most of whom they try to set in front of us and call R&B today;
They trying to sell us the image - selling the sizzle and not the steak.

No matter what, to paraphrase The D.O.C.:

This is not the "who has the best voice" business, the "who looks better on a poster" business, or the "producer" business - this is the "song" business. If your music don't hit, you won't blow up.

Everybody will say all day that Keith Sweat can't sing, but he made it farther than a lot of other artists in this game because he make KNOCKS you can't fucc with.
 

CarmelBarbie

At peace
Supporter
Joined
Nov 19, 2016
Messages
10,600
Reputation
8,594
Daps
58,877
Reppin
Charlotte
But on the same hand those of us are smart can easily just look up all the hood classics / good music on YouTube.

It’s been a plus and a minus. Ella mai was a YouTube singer that did covers. Wasn’t that the same for summer walker? Nowadays anyone with just a little bit of talent can become an artist, and right now a large portion of R&B is coming from mediocre artists being hyped up by a generation that doesn’t know what good music is, those of us that do, do what you said and get on YouTube to play throwbacks.
 

Wear My Dawg's Hat

Superstar
Joined
Nov 18, 2016
Messages
3,532
Reputation
1,950
Daps
15,039
Reppin
The Land That Time Forgot
The examples he gave aren’t talented for the most part. A lot of mediocre artists are being put out there. There’s a big difference between the list you provided and the one he did. One group could actually sing, had talent, and made good music. The other list? Bleh. That’s the only way to describe it. I think with social media, YouTube and whatnot it’s given easier access for people who aren’t very talented to get a Platform.

I think its fair to say that in a social media and cell phones world, music simply does not occupy the center of our culture the way it once did.

So the quality and essence/spirituality of music (what we importantly once referred to as "soul") has diminished tremendously.

The entire craft has become mediocre, marginalized and reduced from what it was, It is well beyond just the artists at this point.
 

CarmelBarbie

At peace
Supporter
Joined
Nov 19, 2016
Messages
10,600
Reputation
8,594
Daps
58,877
Reppin
Charlotte
That's what's wrong with most of whom they try to set in front of us and call R&B today;
They trying to sell us the image - selling the sizzle and not the steak.

No matter what, to paraphrase The D.O.C.:

This is not the "who has the best voice" business, the "who looks better on a poster" business, or the "producer" business - this is the "song" business. If your music don't hit, you won't blow up.

Everybody will say all day that Keith Sweat can't sing, but he made it farther than a lot of other artists in this game because he make KNOCKS you can't fucc with.

Exactly.
 

invalid

Veteran
Joined
Feb 21, 2015
Messages
21,161
Reputation
7,480
Daps
84,977
Ariana Grande is equally risque. Even Britney Spears and them were also back in the day:patrice:.

Hmmm... yeah there is still a difference. Even if we were able to edit out the explicit words in each of the below songs, the latter song is still too much if I got an older relative or a kid around. I’m not going to play that so I would have to default to other songs where the lyrics are not evoking a certain level of sexual explicitness. I wouldn’t want my daughter singing either song tbh but singing the second one would be cringey af. Unfortunately, and I hate to say it, but a lot of the white pop songs are just safer.


Thought I'd end up with Sean
But he wasn't a match
Wrote some songs about Ricky
Now I listen and laugh
Even almost got married
And for Pete, I'm so thankful
Wish I could say, "Thank you" to Malcolm
'Cause he was an angel

One taught me love
One taught me patience
And one taught me pain
Now, I'm so amazing
I've loved and I've lost
But that's not what I see
So, look what I got
Look what you taught me
And for that, I say

Thank you, next (next)
Thank you, next (next)
Thank you, next
I'm so fukkin' grateful for my ex
Thank you, next (next)
Thank you, next (next)
Thank you, next (next)
I'm so fukkin'



VS.

Honestly, I'm tryin' to stay focused
You must think I've got to be joking when I say
I don't think I can wait
I just need it now, better swing my way
I just need some dikk, I just need some love
Tired of fukking with these lame nikkas, baby
I just need a thug
Won't you be my plug? Ayy
You could be the one, ayy
We could start with a handshake, baby
I'ma need more than a hug

Girls can't never say they want it
Girls can't never say how
Girls can't never say they need it
Girls can't never say now
Girls can't never say they want it
Girls can't never say how
Girls can't never say they need it
Girls can't never say now, oh now
 

CASHAPP

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Aug 12, 2012
Messages
26,503
Reputation
-2,474
Daps
48,363
I really need some music heads to breakdown how and why this shyt happened. B/c when I was growing up black artists were KILLING pop. Hell “Thong Song” was everywhere. “Waterfalls”
“I’ll Make Love To You”
“The Boy Is Mine”

brehette I have your answer

it was Rihanna’s cheesy red hair era at the start of the decade that messed it all up. Remember her Loud Album still is and will end up being the biggest selling album of the decade for a black female. I’m dead serious check the stats. She also herself I think has said that was one of her least favorite eras even with that being when she was the biggest

it was the the start of a period where black pop music lost even more soul especially with biracial Canadian drake being a part of it...this wasn’t your old baby face of the 90s writing pop songs....this was Drake...Drakeeee?

this was also during the same period Nicki was giving us cheesy ass pop and then you had their white counterparts in Katy and Gaga. All four are to blame. I know the last two are white but everyone started following their model.

as for what happened prior, after the early 2000s we had that brief period of dancehall where foreign artists were blowing up. The 90s r and b artists of the past that dabbled in pop were on breaks from the industry or retired or had financial issues like TLC. The momentum was gone for many people
 
Top