Now the NY has been irrelevant and dead for over twenty years can we all agree the south killed hip hop?

Street Knowledge

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
27,335
Reputation
2,538
Daps
66,014
Reppin
NYC
Respectfully, who are the stars from the last 20 years?

Ice Spice
Pop Smoke

I say this as someone who wants NYC to return to prominence, reinventing their own sound, and get hip hop out of this quasi-pop, sing songy, BS
How are Nicki and Cardi not stars lol

How is Asap Rocky not a star?

Even Aboogie got 3 certified platinum albums and several platinum singles. Heck he has a diamond single

 
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
22,029
Reputation
22,708
Daps
47,720
Reppin
Chi
How are Nicki and Cardi not stars lol

How is Asap Rocky not a star?

Even Aboogie got 3 certified platinum albums and several platinum singles. Heck he has a diamond single

Fair, I was legit asking, b/c couldn't think of any.

Cardi and Nicki are absolutely stars and probably superstars as their nearly household names outside of hip hip. ASAP is/was a star too. A Boogie has a diamond song which is wild b/c I wouldn't say he's a star, but I can't argue w/ the #s.

My only issue with them is besides Nicki & Cardi's accents you wouldn't be able to tell they're from NYC, but that's my overall issue is that NYC lost it's sound b/c the industry/mainstream sound shifted to down south. I miss being able to hear a song/artist and immeadiately knowing they were from NYC and even which borough. But that isn't NYC's fault, everyone was chasing the new sound to pop in clubs which was ATL.
 

melraH

Superstar
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
6,325
Reputation
2,498
Daps
20,751
Reppin
UPTOWN


:ahh:This Whole Album was a Eulogy that still stands and the worst song is a who done it that's the central point of this thread :ohhh:, Fukking brilliant G.O.A.T shyt
 
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
22,029
Reputation
22,708
Daps
47,720
Reppin
Chi
^everybody sounds like everybody now.
100%

West coast still sounds west coast. Lousiana still has it's sound for the most part, etc.

regionalism is there in the underground. Plenty of underground NYC rappers that are instantly identifiable as NYC artists.

But on a mainstream level, everyone doing the same shyt and it's bland af.
 

Fresh

Superstar
Joined
May 2, 2013
Messages
11,074
Reputation
7,804
Daps
26,500
New York hip-hop artists definitely need to get back to being the pioneers and leaders and being unique

remember in NY rap where if you copied another rapper's style it was a he11 worthy sin ??

It was called "biting", lol

But NY rap needs to reclaim it's own identity, enough following the South and drill

when NY was on top, hip-hop was in good hands, everybody ducked with it

I'm not not even being biased because I had zero problem with West Coast rap when it rose to prominence

but when the Southern/ATL simplistic music took over in the 2000s hip-hop took an L

even The Game said he was tired of hearing nothing but ATL music...and he's from Cali

The South in the 2000s killed hip-hop, it is what it is
 
Joined
May 24, 2022
Messages
1,602
Reputation
254
Daps
1,628
Reppin
Mile High
100%

West coast still sounds west coast. Lousiana still has it's sound for the most part, etc.

regionalism is there in the underground. Plenty of underground NYC rappers that are instantly identifiable as NYC artists.

But on a mainstream level, everyone doing the same shyt and it's bland af.
Very true, but yeah...it's beautiful and ugly at the same time ..
 
Joined
May 24, 2022
Messages
1,602
Reputation
254
Daps
1,628
Reppin
Mile High
New York hip-hop artists definitely need to get back to being the pioneers and leaders and being unique

remember in NY rap where if you copied another rapper's style it was a he11 worthy sin ??

It was called "biting", lol

But NY rap needs to reclaim it's own identity, enough following the South and drill

when NY was on top, hip-hop was in good hands, everybody ducked with it

I'm not not even being biased because I had zero problem with West Coast rap when it rose to prominence

but when the Southern/ATL simplistic music took over in the 2000s hip-hop took an L

even The Game said he was tired of hearing nothing but ATL music...and he's from Cali

The South in the 2000s killed hip-hop, it is what it is
Disagree with this and a lot of things you've said in here.
 

Fresh

Superstar
Joined
May 2, 2013
Messages
11,074
Reputation
7,804
Daps
26,500
Disagree with this and a lot of things you've said in here.

breh, I have zero problems disagreeing, one of the philosophies I live by is "agree to disagree"

it's a beautiful Saturday miday(not in NY right now)

listened to an old Canibus, DMX, and Nore freestyle session, it's all good

but I stand by everything I said, I don't post for daps on shock value, I put thought into my posts, unless I'm making jokes

enjoy your Saturday
 

Knicksman20

Superstar
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Messages
18,376
Reputation
6,028
Daps
52,007
Reppin
NY
As @Wild self has been posting for years, when stripper culture in hip hop started dictating & took the forefront in it is when we started to see the spiral downward.

Also when gate keepers were removed from it & nikkas wanted to start handing out participation awards instead of calling someone wack is another reason
 

Wild self

The Black Man will prosper!
Bushed
Supporter
Joined
Jun 20, 2012
Messages
83,742
Reputation
12,590
Daps
227,493
As @Wild self has been posting for years, when stripper culture in hip hop started dictating & took the forefront in it is when we started to see the spiral downward.

Also when gate keepers were removed from it & nikkas wanted to start handing out participation awards instead of calling someone wack is another reason

Muthafukkas really let hoes and p*ssy dictate a MASCULINE culture to fukkery and parody.
 
Top