I don't agree, I feel most gamers don't really know anything. Phil didn't cancel any games, or order any games to be made. All that would have came with or without Phil Spencer. And all the other ideas they had were great ideas imo, but gamers were too scared to be offline.
Has anyone here tried using their XB1 offline? Anyone? I encourage you to try it today to see if that thing works offline like it should

So all that really happened was we got cheated out of all the cool features they wanted to implement. And they can't count on the "cloud" for computing power in the same way they originally intended. So we are stuck in the present so to speak
Now the Xbox is LESS FUNCTIONAL than it was before phil arrived, and only the casuals who never wanted to give Kinect a chance are saying "Yeah, less features". Meanwhile, this new dashboard is boring as fukk. Leaderboards used to be front and center. I don't scroll thru the bullshyt setup they have now. Not often at least. Cortana isn't as intelligent as she is on PC/Mobile. I be like bytch.. I WANNA GO TO YOUTUBE, NOT THE YOUTUBE WEBSITE (which is actually impressive but I'm venting right now so fukk that)
People are giving too much credit to Phil when all that has happened is a price drop