Prime Calvin Johnson or current Antonio Brown?

Better WR

  • Prime CJ

    Votes: 65 75.6%
  • Antonio Brown

    Votes: 21 24.4%

  • Total voters
    86

The Devil's Advocate

Call me Dad
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
36,616
Reputation
8,160
Daps
100,990
Reppin
Better to reign in Hell than serve in Heaven
We compared stats a while back and AB was way more consistent. Maybe it's triple teams, but CJ would get shut down evvery now and then. AB always put up some kind of numbers. he probably would've broke 2000 last year if Ben didn't get hurt.
Megatron was just big...

Poor route runner...

Dropped A TON of balls...

Got caught from behind a lot...

Coli hate in 5...4...3...2

see but the question was PRIME megatron

2012

Detroit Lions 16 122 1,964 16.1 122.8 53 5 40 5 92 3



played all games... 122 rec for 1964 yards... 122.8 yards a game... 16.1 yards per catch... 5 tds... 92 first downs


yea i'm going to take him THAT prime year vs any year AB had

and imagine what that year would have been on the damn steelers right now instead of the shytty ass lions
 

J Money

Superstar
Joined
May 19, 2014
Messages
10,189
Reputation
2,305
Daps
37,844
see but the question was PRIME megatron

2012

Detroit Lions 16 122 1,964 16.1 122.8 53 5 40 5 92 3



played all games... 122 rec for 1964 yards... 122.8 yards a game... 16.1 yards per catch... 5 tds... 92 first downs


yea i'm going to take him THAT prime year vs any year AB had

and imagine what that year would have been on the damn steelers right now instead of the shytty ass lions

:dwillhuh: You do realise Antonio Brown has 1834 yards last season right? AND 10 touchdown catches to go with that. He would have broken that record if Ben was healthy all last season, easily.

He had 1700 yards 13 TDs in 2014 as well
 

The Devil's Advocate

Call me Dad
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
36,616
Reputation
8,160
Daps
100,990
Reppin
Better to reign in Hell than serve in Heaven
:dwillhuh: You do realise Antonio Brown has 1834 yards last season right? AND 10 touchdown catches to go with that. He would have broken that record if Ben was healthy all last season, easily.

He had 1700 yards 13 TDs in 2014 as well
you realize mega was on the lions with matthew stafford as a qb and a high school team as the offense
 

Ironman

#Knickstape
Joined
Oct 9, 2015
Messages
67,841
Reputation
15,711
Daps
263,745
Reppin
Avengers compound
Only one leader of the decepticons
4BzAvRi_zpslnatbwds.png
 

Millions

Carolina Crook
Supporter
Joined
Oct 20, 2013
Messages
18,827
Reputation
2,092
Daps
44,429
Reppin
Ruff Raleigh, North Carolina
All those sorry QB's are throwing it to Calvin damn near every play to...

People love to bring up the "he played with a sorry qb" argument for a receiver but never bring up that sorry qb is much more likely to lean on that receiver and throw him the ball damn near every play...I would say that more than makes up for another guy having a great QB like Big Ben...who is to smart to be consistently throwing at a triple covered AB...something Stafford never shied away from doing...
:dahell:

So cj only got his numbers cause he was forced fed the ball ?

Megatron was that offense that's far more impressive considering he was beating double and triple teams consistently

That lions O he had surrounding him was some ass
 

J Money

Superstar
Joined
May 19, 2014
Messages
10,189
Reputation
2,305
Daps
37,844
you realize mega was on the lions with matthew stafford as a qb and a high school team as the offense

Still doesn't make a difference in my opinion. In more than confident saying when it's all said and done AB will be considered Top 10 wide out of all-time :yeshrug:
 

Donald Trumps Twitter

Divine Infinite Commander King
Joined
Nov 19, 2014
Messages
14,554
Reputation
1,243
Daps
35,556
Reppin
Space Force 1
see but the question was PRIME megatron

2012

Detroit Lions 16 122 1,964 16.1 122.8 53 5 40 5 92 3



played all games... 122 rec for 1964 yards... 122.8 yards a game... 16.1 yards per catch... 5 tds... 92 first downs


yea i'm going to take him THAT prime year vs any year AB had

and imagine what that year would have been on the damn steelers right now instead of the shytty ass lions

5 TD's is your PRIME example :russell:
 

BreezyH

All Star
Joined
Jun 7, 2013
Messages
2,543
Reputation
350
Daps
4,028
Reppin
Brooklyn
prime calvin seemed unfair to a defense, but ab deserves consideration off his production. calvin was legit scary
 

42 Monks

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Feb 20, 2014
Messages
62,326
Reputation
11,259
Daps
227,921
Reppin
Carolina
All those sorry QB's are throwing it to Calvin damn near every play to...

People love to bring up the "he played with a sorry qb" argument for a receiver but never bring up that sorry qb is much more likely to lean on that receiver and throw him the ball damn near every play...I would say that more than makes up for another guy having a great QB like Big Ben...who is to smart to be consistently throwing at a triple covered AB...something Stafford never shied away from doing...
the fukk is tihs

a shytty qb like stafford can barely throw the ball straight two times in a row

andre johnson and cj were fukking beasts with hobos throwing ducks at them
 
Top