Prime Calvin Johnson or current Antonio Brown?

[The Devil's Advocate]

5 TD's is your PRIME example

take one stat out of 8 brehs

 

[Juggalo Fred]

5 TD's is your PRIME example

the year before he had 1681 yards and 16 TD

 

[Regular_P]

Calvin had 211 yards and 2 TDs in his first playoff game. I'm not trying to read any shyt about Brown helping teams win more because he went to one of the best organizations in the league instead of the worst.

 

[stepbackj34spud]

TO

 

[Nick Barnes]

TO

Moss

 

[Versa]

Hard to compare. Could AB do what Calvin did in Detroit? Can Calvin do what AB does in Pitts?

 

[TrapHouse Rock]

Calvin never had a QB good enough to build a magical rapport with, Ben and AB stay on the same page which is why he goes ape shyt with Ben. Randy Moss went to the pats one year to play with a prime Tom Brady and them motherfukkers were playing pitch and catch rookie mode in Madden


I think by the end of this year AB will be talked about weekly like CJ used to, but CJ was a physical freak who was the only person who could beat you and he'd still rope in 100 yd games like its nothing

 

[duckbutta]

So cj only got his numbers cause he was forced fed the ball ?

Megatron was that offense that's far more impressive considering he was beating double and triple teams consistently

That lions O he had surrounding him was some ass

The only reason...no...

A HUGE reason...yes...



His record setting year...he had 204 targets:dahellwhat:

Somebody throw it to you that much...you going to put up numbers.

The only thing impressive to me about that year is the fact that he only had 5 touchdowns...

That's impossible to score that few touchdowns with that many targets in a year...

You telling me he was beating double and triple coverage?

Not in the red zone he wasn't

Calvin was a great receiver but people act like he is the defacto hands down GOAT receiver ever...

There is a planet Rice cause he was just that good...There is a planet Moss because he is just that good...without even really trying...

There aint no planet Calvin...he on earth with all the other great receivers...

It's going to be a sad day when Calvin get into the HOF and doesn't...

 

[Big Boss]

Megatron

 

[Higher Tech]

AB. Much more versatile wideout.

 

[Panther]

Ab got a legit Qb and maybe the best rb in football

Prime Megatron>

 

[MAGNETO.]

AB gets clamped in the playoffs though

 

[Street Knowledge]

You can be on a "bad" team overall but a good situation in terms of putting up individual numbers

 

[duncanthetall]

You can be on a "bad" team overall but a good situation in terms of putting up individual numbers

How was it a good situation? He's getting doubled and tripled every play with a shyt QB making his job harder and no legitimate other receiving threat. He was their offense.

 

[Detroit Wave]

calvin because he was on a team that was worse than anything the steelers put out. ab on the lions cant match calvins production and calvin on the steelers with first ballot HOFer in big ben is at least 2-3 more chips