Prime for Prime Carmelo or Dwight?

[Loose]

Vs

 

[kuts]

Dwight led his team to the Finals in convincing fashion.

I like Melo, but let's be honest about his game and his results.

 

[Derek Lee]

Prime Dwight easily.

 

[CouldBeWorse]

Prime Dwight was DPOTY 3X and carried his team to the Finals.

Prime Melo never even averaged 30ppg and all he did was score

 

[Sauce Dab]

I don't think it's close tbh. Dwight was winning. I'm not trying to see Melo scoring 60 points in a 10 point loss

 

[CHICAGO]

D12

​

 

[Darealtwo1]

Dwight not even close.

Dwight actually was all world elite at something melo couldn’t spell....Defense.

 

[Double Burger With Cheese]

Much easier to build around prime D12 on both sides of the ball

 

[ba'al]

Dwight he brought the fukking MAGIC to the finals to play against the Lakers that year it was suppose to be a face off with Lebron and Kobe in the finals. All the sports media, commercials, and fans was hyping that shyt up. I still remember the puppet commercials.

 

[2Quik4UHoes]

If that Nuggets team Melo was on had been in the East maybe he makes it to a finals or a few conference finals and it changes this conversation but it’s D12. But these nikkaz is basically opposites of each other. Melo is way better on offense and Dwight was a monster on defense.

 

[rbksNgirbauds]

Dwight he brought the fukking MAGIC to the finals to play against the Lakers that year it was suppose to be a face off with Lebron and Kobe in the finals. All the sports media, commercials, and fans was hyping that shyt up. I still remember the puppet commercials.

I'll never forgive Bron for that shyt. Woulda put a dead end to these Bron vs Kobe stan wars we still see today. That nikka Bron was food back then....and Bean was hungry for some get back against whoever in the finals

 

[staticshock]

Dwight

Prime D12 was a top 5 center of all time

 

[CHICAGO]

If that Nuggets team Melo was on had been in the East maybe he makes it to a finals or a few conference finals and it changes this conversation but it’s D12. But these nikkaz is basically opposites of each other. Melo is way better on offense and Dwight was a monster on defense.

MELO ONLY GOT OUT THE 1ST ROUND 1 TIME...

THATS NOT TRANSLATING TO FINALS
AND MULTIPLE CONFERENCE FINALS APPEARANCES.

HE WOULDNT HAVE BEATEN THE PISTONS,
SHAQ HEAT, CELTICS NOR BRON.



​

 

[ba'al]

I was just happy to see my home team in the finals but really wanted to see kobe and Bron face off in the finals.

I'll never forgive Bron for that shyt. Woulda put a dead end to these Bron vs Kobe stan wars we still see today. That nikka Bron was food back then....and Bean was hungry for some get back against whoever in the finals

 

[El Guapo]

Orlando Dwight was getting 59-win seasons, swatting everything coming to the lane and dunking over you on the other end.