whats the difference between “either love it or hate it” and “divides the fandom”?
Put 6 projects from an artist into these categories
- Thread starter CrimsonTider
- Start date
It’s what you make it tbh
but I think of “either love or hate it” as and album that wasn’t very impactful and probably really is average that draws strong opinions from fans like the game LAX
divides the fandom is an album where an artist went in a different direction and/or find mainstream success at the expense of there traditional sound like Common’s electric circus
It Was Written divided the fan base way more. Nas was being called all types of sellouts, and nikkas were furious they didn't get Illmatic 2. I'd give Fan Favorite to Stillmatic or King's Disease 1.
FF may be Ironman.
The Big Bang is the forgotten one. The Coming has It's A Party, Woo Hah and Everything Remains Raw, which are better and more remembered than anything on The Big Bang.
The one everyone forgets about could be War Angel. Animal Ambition kinda got left where it was
AMW and DC should be reversed, but I won't really fight about it.
"Mental" should be Encore. That's literally what it was.
Ironman and SC should be reversed, but it's debatable.
REDMAN:
Love It Or Hate It: Red Gone Wild
GOAT: Muddy Waters (Really DIAD, but I don't wanna argue with you nikkas)
Overlooked Masterpiece: Whut? Thee Album
Mental Breakdown: DIAD
The One Everyone Forgets About: Ill At Will
Which Divides The Fandom: Malpractice
Fan Favorite: Doc's Da Name
A Tribe Called Quest:
Love It Or Hate It: Thank You For Your Service
GOAT: Midnight Marauders
Overlooked Masterpiece: The Love Movement
The One Everyone Forgets About: PITATPOR
Which Divides The Fandom: Beats, Rhymes And Life
Fan Favorite: The Low End Theory
i was thinking either encore or revival but edged it out to revival
Tommy Gibbs
Superstar
man that shyt is hard to do for my favorite artists because a lot of these guys have 12+ albums haha
Cheese McNair
Bought it this morning, drive it like I stole it
Hmmmm, I see Festivus in your list, which means we including mixtapes... with that said
EITHER LOVE OR HATE IT - FOLARIN 2
GOAT - More About Nothing
OVERLOOKED MASTERPIECE - the gifted
THE ONE EVERYONE FORGETS ABOUT - Shine
WHICH DIVIDES THE FANDOM - Ambition
FAN FAVORITE - Album about nothing
As someone that used to fw Wale, this is accurate. I stopped checking for him after Ambition. More About Nothing was my shyt
Cheese McNair
Bought it this morning, drive it like I stole it
Wiz Khalifa
EITHER LOVE OR HATE IT - ONIFC
GOAT - Kush and OJ
OVERLOOKED MASTERPIECE - Cabin Fever 2
THE ONE EVERYONE FORGETS ABOUT - Blacc Hollywood
WHICH DIVIDES THE FANDOM - Rolling Papers
FAN FAVORITE - Taylor Allderdice
EITHER LOVE OR HATE IT - ONIFC
GOAT - Kush and OJ
OVERLOOKED MASTERPIECE - Cabin Fever 2
THE ONE EVERYONE FORGETS ABOUT - Blacc Hollywood
WHICH DIVIDES THE FANDOM - Rolling Papers
FAN FAVORITE - Taylor Allderdice
Cheese McNair
Bought it this morning, drive it like I stole it
This gone be hard but Ima try to do Spitta
EITHER LOVE OR HATE IT - The Stoned Immaculate
GOAT - Pilot Talk 2
OVERLOOKED MASTERPIECE - Drive in Theatre
THE ONE EVERYONE FORGETS ABOUT - This Ain’t No Mixtape
WHICH DIVIDES THE FANDOM - Canal Street Confidential
FAN FAVORITE - Covert Coup
EITHER LOVE OR HATE IT - The Stoned Immaculate
GOAT - Pilot Talk 2
OVERLOOKED MASTERPIECE - Drive in Theatre
THE ONE EVERYONE FORGETS ABOUT - This Ain’t No Mixtape
WHICH DIVIDES THE FANDOM - Canal Street Confidential
FAN FAVORITE - Covert Coup
Kanye
EITHER LOVE OR HATE IT - Yeezus
GOAT - Late Registration
OVERLOOKED MASTERPIECE - MBDTF
THE ONE EVERYONE FORGETS ABOUT - Ye
WHICH DIVIDES THE FANDOM - 808s and Heartbreak
FAN FAVORITE - College Dropout
EITHER LOVE OR HATE IT - Yeezus
GOAT - Late Registration
OVERLOOKED MASTERPIECE - MBDTF
THE ONE EVERYONE FORGETS ABOUT - Ye
WHICH DIVIDES THE FANDOM - 808s and Heartbreak
FAN FAVORITE - College Dropout
DMX
EITHER LOVE OR HATE IT- And Then there was X
GOAT- It’s Dark
OVERLOOKED MASTERPIECE- It’s Dark (this album need more love)
THE ONE EVERYONE FORGETS ABOUT - Year of Dog
WHICH DIVIDES THE FANDOM- And then there was X
FAN FAVORITE- Flesh of my Flesh
EITHER LOVE OR HATE IT- And Then there was X
GOAT- It’s Dark
OVERLOOKED MASTERPIECE- It’s Dark (this album need more love)
THE ONE EVERYONE FORGETS ABOUT - Year of Dog
WHICH DIVIDES THE FANDOM- And then there was X
FAN FAVORITE- Flesh of my Flesh
Nas
EITHER LOVE OR HATE IT - I Am
GOAT - illmatic
OVERLOOKED MASTERPIECE - Untitled
THE ONE EVERYONE FORGETS ABOUT - Distant Relatives
WHICH DIVIDES THE FANDOM - Street’s Disciple
FAN FAVORITE - It Was Written
EITHER LOVE OR HATE IT - I Am
GOAT - illmatic
OVERLOOKED MASTERPIECE - Untitled
THE ONE EVERYONE FORGETS ABOUT - Distant Relatives
WHICH DIVIDES THE FANDOM - Street’s Disciple
FAN FAVORITE - It Was Written
Cheese McNair
Bought it this morning, drive it like I stole it
Mac Miller
EITHER LOVE OR HATE IT - Divine Feminine
GOAT - Watching Movies
OVERLOOKED MASTERPIECE - Delusional Thomas
THE ONE EVERYONE FORGETS ABOUT - Good AM
WHICH DIVIDES THE FANDOM - Blue Slide Park
FAN FAVORITE - Faces
EITHER LOVE OR HATE IT - Divine Feminine
GOAT - Watching Movies
OVERLOOKED MASTERPIECE - Delusional Thomas
THE ONE EVERYONE FORGETS ABOUT - Good AM
WHICH DIVIDES THE FANDOM - Blue Slide Park
FAN FAVORITE - Faces
Cheese McNair
Bought it this morning, drive it like I stole it
There is nothing overlooked about this. I would’ve put Pablo instead
Fan Favorite for Ghost is Supreme ClienteleIt Was Written divided the fan base way more. Nas was being called all types of sellouts, and nikkas were furious they didn't get Illmatic 2. I'd give Fan Favorite to Stillmatic or King's Disease 1.
FF may be Ironman.
The Big Bang is the forgotten one. The Coming has It's A Party, Woo Hah and Everything Remains Raw, which are better and more remembered than anything on The Big Bang.
The one everyone forgets about could be War Angel. Animal Ambition kinda got left where it was
AMW and DC should be reversed, but I won't really fight about it.
"Mental" should be Encore. That's literally what it was.
Ironman and SC should be reversed, but it's debatable.
REDMAN:
Love It Or Hate It: Red Gone Wild
GOAT: Muddy Waters (Really DIAD, but I don't wanna argue with you nikkas)
Overlooked Masterpiece: Whut? Thee Album
Mental Breakdown: DIAD
The One Everyone Forgets About: Ill At Will
Which Divides The Fandom: Malpractice
Fan Favorite: Doc's Da Name
A Tribe Called Quest:
Love It Or Hate It: Thank You For Your Service
GOAT: Midnight Marauders
Overlooked Masterpiece: The Love Movement
The One Everyone Forgets About: PITATPOR
Which Divides The Fandom: Beats, Rhymes And Life
Fan Favorite: The Low End Theory
How did the fans get divided on anarchy? He had Dilla, Swizz, Nottz and Scratch on it, I feel like they got divided on either genesis or it ain't safe no more. Beats were amazing on Genesis but he was going for a bigger sound and was branching out with producers.
facts also is a compilation billed as a Jay-Z album