Red Dead Redemption or Batman: Arkham City

Black Ball

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
6,758
Reputation
971
Daps
15,444
Reppin
The Mighty LBC
I had more fun playing RDR. I liked AC, but I just wanted to finish and get to the end. I actually had alot more fun playing AA than AC.
 

daze23

Siempre Fresco
Joined
Jun 25, 2012
Messages
32,622
Reputation
2,755
Daps
45,394
Red dead is the better game...I had to remember too much shyt in AC...felt like a chore playing that shyt

AC just feels like they added too much collectable/side-mission shyt. and the world isn't that big, so it's like you're constantly seeing all that Riddler crap everywhere you look. I think that's why some people say the game feels "overwhelming". you see all that crap, and just think...

sweetb.jpg
 

head shots101

North Bronx Blocks!!!
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
25,520
Reputation
3,319
Daps
52,826
Reppin
Bronx Blocks
AC just feels like they added too much collectable/side-mission shyt. and the world isn't that big, so it's like you're constantly seeing all that Riddler crap everywhere you look. I think that's why some people say the game feels "overwhelming". you see all that crap, and just think...

sweetb.jpg

this is true and I didn't do any of the side missions...i'm too lazy for that shyt b
 

Ice Cold

King of Blades
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
6,938
Reputation
1,400
Daps
10,034
I haven't finished AC yet, but IMO AC is the more fun game, RDR is the better experience.
What I mean is that as a game I think batman is better, the combat is really fun and rewarding there's tons of gadgets to use and a ton of stuff to do.
As for RDR the main gameplay mechanic of shooting isn't that great but the storyline, atmosphere, voice acting every thing is great.
So if you "just" want a game get batman, if you want an experience get RDR
 

Bboystyle

FIRE MATT LAFLEUR
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
48,219
Reputation
6,012
Daps
81,291
Reppin
So. Cal
Red Dead got animals u can kill breh. So cop it,invite your PETA friends over and show them whats really going on
 

Phantom

Pro
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
362
Reputation
20
Daps
699
Reppin
Cali
AC isn't a open world game, its as big as AA but not structured linearly. They're some side missions where you have to race across the map and if you have the grapple boost you cross map in a minute.

That being stated I am big spaghetti western and batman fan and I found AC to be more enjoyable.

On a side, Im glad bought the AC GOTY edition off newegg for cheap b/c that Robin DLC was some bullshyt, its short and you play batman half the time :wtb:
 

502Nels

Pro
Joined
May 11, 2012
Messages
1,610
Reputation
70
Daps
1,487
Reppin
TheVille
AC easily. RDR is overrated and got boring to me. A lot of the missions/side missions just aren't that fun to do
 
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
73,308
Reputation
5,920
Daps
174,745
I haven't finished AC yet, but IMO AC is the more fun game, RDR is the better experience.
What I mean is that as a game I think batman is better, the combat is really fun and rewarding there's tons of gadgets to use and a ton of stuff to do.
As for RDR the main gameplay mechanic of shooting isn't that great but the storyline, atmosphere, voice acting every thing is great.
So if you "just" want a game get batman, if you want an experience get RDR
:heh: everyone replying meanwhile i bought Red Dead like 5 hours ago

yo, you right, shooting with the "left trigger" is some ol bullshyt but i guess ill get used to it and i had to put the subtitles on to understand those hick voices but i do think this game will be piff. Only had time to play for a little bit but ill get into it more tonight


had to kill rabbits and wolves at that white chick's ranch so far :ohlawd:
 

stepbackj34spud

Top 75 All-Time
Joined
May 23, 2012
Messages
32,125
Reputation
-5,494
Daps
65,244
Reppin
BK
You Probably Have A Short Attention Span Bruh

I hated it since day 1. The hyped that game up by saying the multiplayer was very much like an mmo... On SOHh nikkas was like :ooh:

But when the game dropped the multiplayer was some of the most ass shyt I've ever played in any Gen. The SP wasn't too hot either. Rockstar makes so many shytty and boring games, yet people eat them up because they make GTA.
 

FlyRy

Veteran
Joined
May 11, 2012
Messages
31,870
Reputation
3,675
Daps
65,455
I hated it since day 1. The hyped that game up by saying the multiplayer was very much like an mmo... On SOHh nikkas was like :ooh:

But when the game dropped the multiplayer was some of the most ass shyt I've ever played in any Gen. The SP wasn't too hot either. Rockstar makes so many shytty and boring games, yet people eat them up because they make GTA.

:birdman:

online was really fun. free roam mode was GOAT.

then u still have deathmatch and the mexican standoffs

single player was all-time goat level.

MARSTON DA GAWD!
 
Top