Count me in to the group that looks at East a lil funny. I was on his wave early (early for a non-New Yotker anyway), probably four or five years ago. But I never bought the street shyt. It doesn't emanate naturally from him and too many people with knowledge of his situation shoot that image down...
As far as the imagery and posturing he like his idol Nas, and they both from Queens lol...
East also used to live in Richmond, VA. Either he did a year of high school there or a year of college, but he spent a year there and there's a few heads floating around who knew him/were in proximity or had contact with him in Richmond...
The two things I can identify with East about. 1)some of us do grow up in a lot of different places, for different reasons. I believe he lived in Harlem at some point, i don't think he just made it up without ever having lived there. Myself, I'm from California and grew up all over the place because of a fukked up family background, but i still represent myself as being from California. Everybody not just born and raised in one or two places. I can relate to that, and he probably was told everywhere he lived he wasnt from there lol...
2)I went to grade/elementary school in the Harlems in LA, so its nostalgic watching his videos in LA with the Harlems at parks and on streets I used to walk down/around...
But the street stories, never bought em!
I've never deliberately went back and played his music, so I'm not a fan at all but I saw his documentary and it prortrayed "a regular nikka" he may have even said "I'm just a regular nikka". Music is fukking music. I'm a regular nikka but I've thought and said "I will kill you" and I even though I didn't do it I meant it and if I was a rapper I could said it on a song. I've also hustled even though I'm not"a hustler". Just saying.
Saying "I'll kill you" and meaning it is different than portraying the image of a shooter; having messed with drugs at some point is different than having actually been someone who made theh livelihood and reputation from being a dealer...
East's lyrics portray a specific imagery that in all likelihood isn't realistic. He could say he messed around before (Cole has mentioned him trying to deal briefly) or if somebody caught him wrong he'd shoot them (Kendrick has mentioned this) without portraying the image of someone who is of that cloth. There's a big difference...
I think nikkas of that cloth recognize that East isn't one of them anyway...