Rod Woodson or Ed Reed?

[Remote]

Think posters are white cause they think intelligently and are able to write clearly and concisely brehs

You really took that post to heart after bytching about people taking my threads seriously

 

[SoulController]

Ed is one of my GOATs but Rod made Pro Bowl at both S spots after he couldnt play cb anymore. Charles and Rod Woodson might be the most complete db's ever (along with Lott who some forget played corner for years)

i plead the 5th

 

[Loose]

Everybody picking Woodson is doing the old school nostalgia bullshyt. Nobody played the ball on the air better than reed, he also knows how to find the end zone better too

You talking like rod woodson played in the 60s or some shyt

 

[Swaggatron]

Everybody picking Woodson is doing the old school nostalgia bullshyt. Nobody played the ball on the air better than reed, he also knows how to find the end zone better too

Would you play Reed 1 on 1 with everyones 1 WR with no safety help

 

[Remote]

Rod spent his best years as a corner. It's an apples to oranges comparison.

I don't see why they can't be compared.

If you ranked the best athletes of all time, it's obviously comparing apples and oranges trying to contrast Michael Jordan with Muhammad Ali.

If you rank the best basketball players of all time, you're obviously comparing apples and oranges trying to contrast a guard like Magic to a center like Shaq.

Suddenly with football there's a problem?

I didn't ask who was the best corner. Or the best safety.
I asked who was better.

Frankly it's a fair question.

 

[Mantis Toboggan M.D.]

I don't see why they can't be compared.

If you ranked the best athletes of all time, it's obviously comparing apples and oranges trying to contrast Michael Jordan with Muhammad Ali.

If you rank the best basketball players of all time, you're obviously comparing apples and oranges trying to contrast a guard like Magic to a center like Shaq.

Suddenly with football there's a problem?

I didn't ask who was the best corner. Or the best safety.
I asked who was better.

Frankly it's a fair question.

A corner has totally different responsibilities from a free safety. It's the same type of reason that the Troy/Reed comparison wasn't a good one. Their skill sets were complimentary, not overlapping. By the time rod switched to safety, his best years were behind him and while he was a great safety, he wasn't as good as Reed was.

 

[Remote]

A corner has totally different responsibilities from a free safety. It's the same type of reason that the Troy/Reed comparison wasn't a good one. Their skill sets were complimentary, not overlapping. By the time rod switched to safety, his best years were behind him and while he was a great safety, he wasn't as good as Reed was.

And a center has different responsibilities than a point guard.



I appreciate all the opinions toward Rod and Ed.
But to act like its an unfair question is, I think, unfair.

 

[L. Deezy]

should have been Ed Reed vs Lott

I swear I cant choose who the GOAT between the 2

 

[duncanthetall]

I don't see why they can't be compared.

If you ranked the best athletes of all time, it's obviously comparing apples and oranges trying to contrast Michael Jordan with Muhammad Ali.

If you rank the best basketball players of all time, you're obviously comparing apples and oranges trying to contrast a guard like Magic to a center like Shaq.

Suddenly with football there's a problem?

I didn't ask who was the best corner. Or the best safety.
I asked who was better.

Frankly it's a fair question.

Theyre different positions. Just because they're both defense doesn't mean it's a fair comparison. Come on man.

 

[mastermind]

Woodson has a case as the GOAT defensive back.

Its Woodson

 

[Remote]

Theyre different positions. Just because they're both defense doesn't mean it's a fair comparison. Come on man.

So when someone here makes a thread asking who the best player in the NFL is, do you all throw your hands up and call bullshyt because Tom Brady can't be compared to Von Miller??

 

[BmoreGorilla]

Obviously Reed but I'm biased. He was super man on the field and was more important to the Ravens D than Ray Lewis at one point

 

[Illeye buckmatic]

Rod for the versatility

 

[duncanthetall]

So when someone here makes a thread asking who the best player in the NFL is, do you all throw your hands up and call bullshyt because Tom Brady can't be compared to Von Miller??

You're fukking dense man. I'm not doing this

 

[Remote]

You're fukking dense man. I'm not doing this

Or you're just upset because you forgot players that man different positions are compared all the time.