Saysumthinfunnymike
VOTE!!!
Big Ben ended up being the best of the 3 but none of them reached top of the league status 
Roethlisberger-Eli Manning-Rivers... These guys are done
- Thread starter CrimsonTider
- Start date
Two of them won two SBs. All three provided a decade+ of stability at the position.Big Ben ended up being the best of the 3 but none of them reached top of the league status
Any team that drafts (or trades for) a QB would sign up for any of their careers without thought.
May be the end of the line for all of them. They have all been in the league for damn near 15 years so it shouldn't be a shock that all of them have slowed down or are thinking about retirement at this point.
filial_piety
Banned
Eli has never been an elite QB..he's probably in the small group of QBs with 2 SBs who won't make the HOF in our lifetimes (the other two being Jim Plunkett and Phil SImms)...he has that iron man attendance tho...
Rivers has never been "elite" really but h'es had some really solid seasons in passing yards and a high QB rating...but let's face it...the kid has been in the league 13 or 14 seasons...and really hasn't accomplished anything
Ben is HOF material--no doubt imo...he was heavily contemplating retirement last season...and I haven't seen him play this season yet...but it wouldn't surprise me if he was washed at this point...last season he was looking
but they all 3 could get the
at this point in they career....they're basically just taking a spot some youngin could have.
Rivers has never been "elite" really but h'es had some really solid seasons in passing yards and a high QB rating...but let's face it...the kid has been in the league 13 or 14 seasons...and really hasn't accomplished anything
Ben is HOF material--no doubt imo...he was heavily contemplating retirement last season...and I haven't seen him play this season yet...but it wouldn't surprise me if he was washed at this point...last season he was looking
but they all 3 could get the
the next guy
Superstar
Ben was up there win Tom, Manning and them in the mid 2000s.Big Ben ended up being the best of the 3 but none of them reached top of the league status
Anyway, father time has caught up with all three.
And still is!
Rep the systemAnd Brady has 5 tds
BlueHeffner
Veteran
Lol no the hell he wasnt
The fukk he wasn't.
The Giants had the worst defense in the division in the regular season, gave up the most QB pressures in the NFL, and had the NFL's worst run game and he, with gawdly WR trio, still kept that team alive until the defense got hot late so they could go on a run. He then went on one of the best postseason runs any QB has ever had, pure statistics to surviving an all-time ass kicking to again making one of the greatest plays in Super Bowl history.
You can talk some shyt about a lot of points in Eli's career, but 2011 is off limits.
BlueHeffner
Veteran
Eli's 2011 season was not better than Romo's
Romo beat him in:
Completion %
TDs
QB Rating
and threw less picks
Where's Romo now and how many chips did he bring Dallas ?
BlueHeffner
Veteran
Deflect when you can't actually have an intellectual debateWhere's Romo now and how many chips did he bring Dallas ?
Deflect when you can't actually have an intellectual debate
is exactly what you did with this comment
