Rolling Stones' Top 200 Hip Hop Albums

[mobbinfms]

If you want to argue that Missy Elliot deserves an album in the top 200 of all time, I could probably go with that but to have 3 in the list and one in the top 10 above 36 Chambers and Low End Theory (not to mention all the others like The Chronic) is absolutely insane IMO and they only did it for virtue signalling reasons

It’s flat out fukking absurd

 

[Yagirlcheatinonus]

Biggie #1

 

[JustCKing]

Once upon a time TheColi did a debate/vote for a top 10 list and I have good faith that TheColi could present a better album list if done in this manner as well

The Coli's list would be as bad because I can guarantee only 20 artists tops would be represented on that list, maybe less:

Nas- most of his catalog would be on the list with Illmatic at #1

Jay- most of his catalog

OutKast- probably the first five albums

Wu- first two albums and most of the solos from '95-'06

Dre- both Chronics

Kanye- first three albums and MBDTF

Quik- two or three albums

Mobb Deep- Infamous, Hell On Earth, Murda Muzik

Pac- every album he released while alive and Makaveli.

Biggie- both albums

Little Brother- first two albums

Kendrick Lamar- most of his catalog

 

[mobbinfms]

Mobb Deep- Infamous, Hell On Earth, Murda Muzik

These three albums should be on a top 200 though

 

[JustCKing]

These three albums should be on a top 200 though

Didn't say they didn't. I made the post to illustrate that The Booth's Top 200 would be just as crazy as this one.

 

[mobbinfms]

Didn't say they didn't. I made the post to illustrate that The Booth's Top 200 would be just as crazy as this one.

It would be way better than this list.

 

[JustCKing]

It would be way better than this list.

If The Booth put up a list and made it public, it would be ripped to shreds much like this one. The only way to properly male a list like that is to list the albums without ranking them like The Source did in 1998.

 

[mobbinfms]

If The Booth put up a list and made it public, it would be ripped to shreds much like this one. The only way to properly male a list like that is to list the albums without ranking them like The Source did in 1998.

I disagree wholeheartedly. The Booth would have a far superior list.

 

[JustCKing]

I disagree wholeheartedly. The Booth would have a far superior list.

I put my account on the line that The Booth's list would be trash. Only way I could see it not being trash is if @DANJ!, @spliz, and some other reputable posters who weren't biased oversaw the list.

 

[mobbinfms]

I put my account on the line that The Booth's list would be trash. Only way I could see it not being trash is if @DANJ!, @spliz, and some other reputable posters who weren't biased oversaw the list.

You don’t have to put your account on the line. You are a valuable part of this community
@spliz and @DANJ! would make a highly credible top 200

 

[prophecypro]

The Coli's list would be as bad because I can guarantee only 20 artists tops would be represented on that list, maybe less:

Nas- most of his catalog would be on the list with Illmatic at #1

Jay- most of his catalog

OutKast- probably the first five albums

Wu- first two albums and most of the solos from '95-'06

Dre- both Chronics

Kanye- first three albums and MBDTF

Quik- two or three albums

Mobb Deep- Infamous, Hell On Earth, Murda Muzik

Pac- every album he released while alive and Makaveli.

Biggie- both albums

Little Brother- first two albums

Kendrick Lamar- most of his catalog

This is already better than Rolling Stone's



2010's artist should be on a greatest ever list but some of their picks were questionable (Flo Milli, City Girls) They were forcing it

 

[prophecypro]

And Missy should have multiple albums in the top 200 but that album in the top 10 is kinda wild especially over some other albums that werent

 

[JustCKing]

This is already better than Rolling Stone's



2010's artist should be on a greatest ever list but some of their picks were questionable (Flo Milli, City Girls) They were forcing it

It would be cool until you realize, the entire Top 20 is mostly Nas and Jay Z albums with a few other albums thrown in the mix.

 

[prophecypro]

It would be cool until you realize, the entire Top 20 is mostly Nas and Jay Z albums with a few other albums thrown in the mix.

Still fine with that as long as the other 180 are mixed

 

[O.Red]

Nobody even tries to do shyt like this in good faith anymore. Whole list is engagement-bait

Exactly. And nikkas took the bait

Honestly we as a society are past these dumb ass lists