Rosenberg steals Coli members MC ranking system & Passes it off as his own

[kingofnyc]

@mobbinfms look who stole our idea


Rosenbug himself...

but his system is much different from yours
reason being.... rosenburg has mc's ranked by years that didnt put out any type of body of work in that year

didnt he have rakim for 8 years straight at No1 -starting in '87 although he only drop'd 4 album during that span

 

[kingofnyc]

Its gonna be flawed way of looking when Big and Pac totally drop off the list but Drake is ranked higher just off points on year by year

well, he did say something like, even tho said rapper may have passed away or retired... they still qualified to be on the list

i believe he did this to boost his favorite rapper big pun
but ultimately this would really on benefit biggie

 

[SunZoo]

He didnt need to do all this to justify his own personal list.

Unless he intends this to be an objective list that holds weight to other people. I hope not.

Well he is the media authority on Hip Hop right?

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

Well he is the media authority on Hip Hop right?

You can't read.

I'm saying this ranking system has its benefits, not rosenbergs entries.

 

[mobbinfms]

but his system is much different from yours
reason being.... rosenburg has mc's ranked by years that didnt put out any type of body of work in that year

didnt he have rakim for 8 years straight at No1 -starting in '87 although he only drop'd 4 album during that span

Exactly. What made @Inspect Her Deck system much better is that alone. Not to mention the weighting which he hasn't even considered yet.

 

[Wacky D]

people will diss Rosenberg, then turn around and swear by the source's old mic ratings system, like it aint the same chit as the video. white dudes & black nerds. yall BEEN letting them dictate the culture. theyre just being up front about it now instead of hiding behind print.

and as bad as this video is, HE CAN DO WHAT HE WANTS. and as flawed as the system is, at least it opens up fun side-convos concerning each year.

BOTTOM LINE black people need to start stepping up and taking interest in the culture like this
and for people like myself that do step up, a lot of yall try to snub or diss when we do something. but yall run to the Rosenberg threads whenever he farts.

 

[Wacky D]

this dude Rosenberg just said rap didn't get competitive until '87.

then he'll turn around and rank the past 10 years, which are the years when competitive aspect of rap was eliminated. but he''ll rank that chit and call Kendrick the goat.

hes better off just saying he doesn't know about the previous eras before rakim/KRS.

 

[kingofnyc]

This is a silly system. If you're going to add points like this then you're going to need another system in place to account for the level of competition. Otherwise the comparisons from different eras are way out of wack.

If you applied it to something like boxing, then that Klitschko dude is the goat heavyweight, better than Ali, Fraizer, etc because he dominated a dead division for like 10 years.

It's way more impressive to be a top 3 MC from 94-97 than to be a top 3 MC from...say 2008-2011 but this system weighs then equally.

thats been my analogy from day 1

that mid 90's hiphop era is to late 60's early 70's. heavy weight boxing era

ali, frazier, forman, norton, listen, patterson, quarrey & holmes
is to
biggie, jay z, nas, cube, 3 stacks, ghost, rea, pun, snoop, pac & prodigy

 

[SunZoo]

You can't read.

I'm saying this ranking system has its benefits, not rosenbergs entries.

So I can't read because....I wasn't talking to or about you?

I can read just fine, the system



Even the coveted mic system is arbitrary.

 

[SunZoo]

people will diss Rosenberg, then turn around and swear by the source's old mic ratings system, like it aint the same chit as the video. white dudes & black nerds. yall been letting them dictate the culture. theyre just being up front about it now instead of hiding behind print.

and as bad as this video is, HE CAN DO WHAT HE WANTS. and as flawed as the system is, at least it opens up fun side-convos concerning each year.

BOTTOM LINE black people need to start stepping up and taking interest in the culture like this
and for people like myself that do step up, a lot of yall try to snub or diss when we do something. but yall run to the Rosenberg threads whenever he farts.

I just said that, didn't even catch that you already pointed out. I mean I used the system, it's simple but it's arbitrary. When people started adding decimals and aggregates and taking them way too serious...

 

[kingofnyc]

he could be a premiere nikka in the conscience lane,but we all know that ain't getting you into goat discussion...maybe that's unfortunate but no conscience rapper has been able to do it convincingly yet,and it ain't about to start with kendrick....hope your not arguing it's too soon,discography not big enough,under the circumstances

my major argument with kendrick is era
he a pretty good rapper surrounded by a ton of garbage

 

[That Singer Guy...]

@ReasonableMatic

Not trying to steal your thread but I can't allow Rosenberg to culture vulture some shyt off thecoli.

@Inspect Her Deck it look like you fighting a losing battle in here, I got you brethren.

 

[kingofnyc]

His NY and White emcee bias in on full display.

I'd already majority consensus 2Pac is the GOAT, but these geeks gotta keep changing criteria to discredit him

not wanting to turn this into ur typical biggie vs pac

but rosenburg was a pretty much correct on the movement in '94 '95 - nikkaz wasn't fiending for pac shyt until deathrow/drama

 

[mobbinfms]

people will diss Rosenberg, then turn around and swear by the source's old mic ratings system, like it aint the same chit as the video. white dudes & black nerds. yall been letting them dictate the culture. theyre just being up front about it now instead of hiding behind print.

and as bad as this video is, HE CAN DO WHAT HE WANTS. and as flawed as the system is, at least it opens up fun side-convos concerning each year.

BOTTOM LINE black people need to start stepping up and taking interest in the culture like this
and for people like myself that do step up, a lot of yall try to snub or diss when we do something. but yall run to the Rosenberg threads whenever he farts.

You think Reginald Dennis was a black nerd?

 

[mobbinfms]

not wanting to turn this into ur typical biggie vs pac

but rosenburg was a pretty much correct on the movement in '94 '95 - nikkaz wasn't fiending for pac shyt until deathrow/drama

Nah. He glossed over MATW like he never heard it