Serious question, is Arch Manning even a good quarterback??

[Lucky_Lefty]

The way folks went out their way to shyt on Ewers, he better win every award known to man and a natty this season

 

[cobra]

was good in high school

 

[MostReal]

He has two career starts against UL Monroe and MIss St. Why are people talking about teams tanking for him or even seen as the #1 overall pick next year?

I haven't seen anything from him to make him elite. His high school tape was average too

 

[Tony D'Amato]

Ain't he have a broke neck?

A shoulder that he fukked up while skiing. Peyton had the broken neck. And he played till his arm was a noodle. He had to be dragged off the field. Now thats a franchise starting qb.

Brady gave up a marriage and who knows what else. Thats dedication

 

[Tony D'Amato]

Andrew Luck is a soft ass bytch who had the luxury of playing for one of the most underrated coaches of all time at the right time.

Got to the NFL and showed just how big his Vagina was.

And they let GOAT walk away for that hoe

Who was the underrated coach?

Arch just have to look like Eli Manning this season and he's going 1. I think he's already better than Eli.

 

[Phantum]

I don't even know what CAC looks like but I'm ready for the tank

 

[MegaTronBomb!]

I don't really see the comparison.

Clausen was frail, one-dimensional, predictable and far too timid. Arch is pretty much the opposite to that.

The fact that he comes from "good stock" ( also a 3rd generation QB) and dominated in HS holds more weight than his actual play in college has warranted.

It's parallel to when Clausen went to ND

Nothing more, nothing less.