Settle a debate: Juvenile on Fire vs. Marshall Mathers

[smokeurobinson]

That's how the debate started with my boy...But then he said that nothing on 400 Degreez was as good as Marshall Mathers (quality wise) and I took humbrage.

What's your thoughts on album vs album and song vs song

Both albums give me nostalgia of when I was in the Army...They're both period pieces for me.



When I hear Back That Ass up i always go back to spring 99 when the video was hot and my son was a baby....When Kill You comes on I immediatly think of the AOL noise the computer would make when logging onto the internet.


I'm gonna stay outta this one..

 

[ReturnOfJudah]

400 degreez album>>>> emenim's existence

 

[Lord Poison]

But u know this site hates on Em. Were u looking for an objective comparison or did u already know that no one would pick Em on this site (hence no one has picked Em in 2 pages) and u just used this thread as some sorta evidence to show ya boy?

Ask the same question on this Eminem messageboard...see if u get similiar results.

Eminem Forum • Eminem Forum

Yeah, don't ask people on a general Hip Hop forum, ask people on a biased fan site of the artist that you like.

 

[DaveyDave]

400 Degreez IMO is better as an album and On Fire is better as a song even thought it's a completely random and meaningless comparison as a song.

 

[tuckgod]

On Fire >>>>>>> Em's catalog

 

[smokeurobinson]

Yeah, don't ask people on a general Hip Hop forum, ask people on a biased fan site of the artist that you like.

I was actually being sarcastic by posting a fan site but u didnt catch it.


That was my way of saying that this messageboard is anti Eminem. And u cant say otherwise because it is. If u wanna win a bet against Eminem just make a thread here and match him up against anything, like a bowl of shyt...the bowl of shyt will win everytime. Look at the responses in this thread.

 

[Terrance Curtis Beasley]

Juvenile