Shedeur Sanders vs Caleb Williams as NFL prospects

[Stop_It_5]

My main concern with Caleb is that he's been playing on rookie mode with Riley so far in college. Obviously a big part of that is him making it such, but the lack of adversity tends to hit players in his position like a brick once they reach the pros. It's why the Urb shytshow almost ruined Trevor, and it'll be even easier for something like that to wreck Caleb with his bad habits (sitting in clean pockets for 10 seconds with the happy feet).


I don't think Shedeur's better than him in any physical trait but the mental toughness and fortitude is probably on a different level. It's the type of journey thats gonna have him more ready from day one, and that's gonna blend well with his composure and comfort from the pocket.

 

[Trav]

Shedeur

Not falling for the in the tailpipe

 

[Trojan 24]

Caleb Williams is going to be a bust

Panthers gonna trade Baby Body to my Raiders when they get that #1 pick

 

[Trojan 24]

My main concern with Caleb is that he's been playing on rookie mode with Riley so far in college. Obviously a big part of that is him making it such, but the lack of adversity tends to hit players in his position like a brick once they reach the pros. It's why the Urb shytshow almost ruined Trevor, and it'll be even easier for something like that to wreck Caleb with his bad habits (sitting in clean pockets for 10 seconds with the happy feet).


I don't think Shedeur's better than him in any physical trait but the mental toughness and fortitude is probably on a different level. It's the type of journey thats gonna have him more ready from day one, and that's gonna blend well with his composure and comfort from the pocket.

Besides TCU, Baby Prime has had the more talented team in pretty much every college game he's played though. That's going to change here very quickly

 

[West Coast Avenger]

Caleb Williams is going to be a bust

....who's your QB gonna be next week?.........

 

[Ruck]

Maye, Penix and Ewers are all better.

Stop it, sir. We not finna do dis

 

[Apprentice]

Stop it, sir. We not finna do dis

Ewers is like that but i'll take Shedeur rn because he is obviously a far better decision maker

 

[Lucky_Lefty]

Stop it, sir. We not finna do dis

No, let's do this.

 

[Lucky_Lefty]

I don't think Shedeur's better than him in any physical trait but the mental toughness and fortitude is probably on a different level. It's the type of journey thats gonna have him more ready from day one, and that's gonna blend well with his composure and comfort from the pocket.

 

[RadaMillz]

Penix >>>>>>

 

[jay211]

Shedeur is a better QB than Ewers. I don't like Ewers decision making and he's NOT accurate. Shedeur is better than Maye too.

I think Caleb has the slightly higher ceiling. But I think Shedeur has the Brady killer instinct. And also is super accurate. Athleticism is what Caleb has over Shedeur.

But besides that, I'd take Shedeur.

 

[Ruck]

Shedeur is a better QB than Ewers. I don't like Ewers decision making and he's NOT accurate. Shedeur is better than Maye too.

I think Caleb has the slightly higher ceiling. But I think Shedeur has the Brady killer instinct. And also is super accurate. Athleticism is what Caleb has over Shedeur.

But besides that, I'd take Shedeur.

U see it

 

[Apprentice]

Shedeur is a better QB than Ewers. I don't like Ewers decision making and he's NOT accurate. Shedeur is better than Maye too.

I think Caleb has the slightly higher ceiling. But I think Shedeur has the Brady killer instinct. And also is super accurate. Athleticism is what Caleb has over Shedeur.

But besides that, I'd take Shedeur.

pump the breaks on shedeur better than Maye

 

[Ruck]

pump the breaks on shedeur better than Maye

Nah. We on full tilt

 

[Avisible Man]

The lightskin one named Caleb

The darkskin one named Shedeur

Easy choice for an NFL exec looking for the next face of their franchise