Should penalties be be challenged in the NFL

[LordLyons]

NFL will consider allowing coaches to challenge all penalties

Sick of seeing games being decided by officials. People say the games would be longer but I don't care.

 

[tremonthustler1]

No. They're judgment calls.

 

[basketball reasons]

they should be confirmed automatically at a central location within seconds of it happening. If its not a penalty have it rescinded on the spot

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

No. They're judgment calls.

Why can't judgement be reviewed?

Edit: and they're NOT just judgement calls. Many times they're phantom visions. A ref *thinks* they saw the ball cross the goal line, replay shows it did not, we overturn it. A ref *thinks* they saw the defender push the receiver before the ball got there, replay shows he did not, but we're stuck with the consequences. Why?

 

[LordLyons]

if you're a fan of one of the golden teams (steelers packers patriots cowboys) of course you wouldn't want this to be

your team would directly be affected by this rule if it were passed

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

they should be confirmed automatically at a central location within seconds of it happening. If its not a penalty have it rescinded on the spot

They are proposing to get rid of the booth and just use tablets with the VP of officiating making the call from a central location. I like that, should speed reviews up. As long as the tablets work.

 

[Bone$]

Pass interference. Has to be. Fukkin 58 yard penalties are a joke

 

[Da_Eggman]

I don't got 5 hours to watch a game

 

[Doobie Doo]

ON one hand I want to say yes, cuz I've seen the wrong call lose a team the game.

But the fan side of me does not want another stoppage in gameplay

And both side know some Bill Belly Chick ass muthafukka will be abusing the system using the stoppage as part of their team strategy

 

[LordLyons]

I don't got 5 hours to watch a game

so you think every penalty is going to be challenged when coaches only have 2 challenge flags and you think that would extend a 3 hour game to 5 hours

 

[Da_Eggman]

so you think every penalty is going to be challenged when coaches only have 2 challenge flags and you think that would extend a 3 hour game to 5 hours

I'm busy bruh we gotta move this game along

 

[Omar Little]

We trying to shoot eyes out now ?

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

I don't got 5 hours to watch a game

Coaches are still only allowed 2(+1) challenges, what makes you think games would become dramatically longer?

 

[Da_Eggman]

Coaches are still only allowed 2(+1) challenges, what makes you think games would become dramatically longer?

I'm going thru some issues

 

[tremonthustler1]

Why can't judgement be reviewed?

Edit: and they're NOT just judgement calls. Many times they're phantom visions. A ref *thinks* they saw the ball cross the goal line, replay shows it did not, we overturn it. A ref *thinks* they saw the defender push the receiver before the ball got there, replay shows he did not, but we're stuck with the consequences. Why?

If we're gonna review every call we think a ref fukked up, don't have refs