Should Samoa Joe be the big time player for AEW in his aging years?

Trips

Superstar
Joined
Feb 3, 2016
Messages
16,233
Reputation
2,473
Daps
46,240
I feel that ultimately the next AEW champ is Adam Cole. And I really don't feel Adam's the right guy to be the next World Champ. But everything in this storyline with MJF feels like that is where this is all going no matter what. Having Joe beat MJF would put a twist on things. I feel Joe should beat MJF and become the next champ. Let Joe do what he does and kind of freshen up their ME scene with some new challengers. I just don't see it/expect it to happen. And it sucks. Cause I think there is a more open story to tell with MJF/Cole now that they made them actual ROH Tag Team champs that doesn't have to revolve around the fact that MJF is also the AEW champ.
 

MenacingMonk

War & Peace
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
65,823
Reputation
8,660
Daps
142,213
Reppin
West where the Sunsets
I feel that ultimately the next AEW champ is Adam Cole. And I really don't feel Adam's the right guy to be the next World Champ. But everything in this storyline with MJF feels like that is where this is all going no matter what. Having Joe beat MJF would put a twist on things. I feel Joe should beat MJF and become the next champ. Let Joe do what he does and kind of freshen up their ME scene with some new challengers. I just don't see it/expect it to happen. And it sucks. Cause I think there is a more open story to tell with MJF/Cole now that they made them actual ROH Tag Team champs that doesn't have to revolve around the fact that MJF is also the AEW champ.
Keep Cole away from the main belt. I truly believe the product’s interest will decline if he wins it. :scust:
 
Last edited:

Ribbs

Veteran
Joined
May 25, 2015
Messages
22,712
Reputation
4,072
Daps
90,569
Reppin
Toronto
I'd prefer him as champion because I don't see the MJF/Cole friendship lasting long. I'll give them props for trying something totally new but this doesn't have long legs to me. Joe is box office and can be trusted to run with the title for a while. After the Punk diabolical, they need an adult in the room who isn't about that high school shyt.
 

MenacingMonk

War & Peace
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
65,823
Reputation
8,660
Daps
142,213
Reppin
West where the Sunsets
I'd prefer him as champion because I don't see the MJF/Cole friendship lasting long. I'll give them props for trying something totally new but this doesn't have long legs to me. Joe is box office and can be trusted to run with the title for a while. After the Punk diabolical, they need an adult in the room who isn't about that high school shyt.
Have Cole cost MJF the belt, build the split, let them feud for 2-3 months.
 

Cattle Mutilation

Superstar
Joined
Dec 7, 2016
Messages
32,860
Reputation
1,538
Daps
50,713
Have Samoa Joe win the belt. Have Adam Cole beat Joe for the belt after Joe refuses to give MJF a rematch. Then you can run the breakup angle between Cole and MJF.
 

DLo

All Star
Supporter
Joined
Sep 15, 2012
Messages
3,369
Reputation
495
Daps
10,263
Joe needs a long run as champ. Not sure why they were wasting him with all that ROH shyt
 

Rollie Forbes

Drapetomaniac.
Joined
Aug 10, 2017
Messages
74,601
Reputation
16,665
Daps
231,338
Samoa Joe is one of the most believable wrestlers on the AEW roster from a visual standpoint. He has a logical, but still safe, old-school wrestling style, and he's 20 years younger than Jericho.
Give Joe a lengthy title run and let him restore the world title belt's prestige.
 

Redguard

Hoonding
Joined
Oct 18, 2013
Messages
12,450
Reputation
1,796
Daps
34,520
Reppin
Hammerfell
Samoa Joe is one of the most believable wrestlers on the AEW roster from a visual standpoint. He has a logical, but still safe, old-school wrestling style, and he's 20 years younger than Jericho.
Give Joe a lengthy title run and let him restore the world title belt's prestige.

MJF needs to drop the AEW World title to..

ricky-starks.gif
 

Ripp

Superstar
Joined
Jul 27, 2012
Messages
19,071
Reputation
1,595
Daps
39,202
Reppin
Queens
At 44, He’s better than 90% of the roster….


Across both companies :manny:

Age shouldn't matter unless you can visibly tell that someone is falling off. I legit thought Joe was in his 30s until I Googled it.

Even though it doesn't make sense because I was watching him on TNA as a teenager so he has to be older than me. Im 35 so realistically Joe could be 38 if he started at 18 or some shyt.

But yeah as long as he's not decrepit it shouldn't matter
 

julesocean

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Apr 10, 2015
Messages
8,094
Reputation
2,301
Daps
19,123
World title match set for their big year-end PPV. Will no doubt be apart of the Devil shenanigans. MJF have a year reign under his belt, he can now drop it.

The chance to give Joe a monster heel run with the title in 2024 is right there for the picking.

Your call Tony.
 
Top