Gamers played more than just boring PS3 exclusives. That way, they wouldn't feel compelled to hype up bullshyt boring ass games
UC1 was decent. 2 was epic, 3 was average. Last of Us is extremely overrated and once the newness wears off we'll properly judge that game.
Theres series like Bioshock, Bethesda with Skyrim, Elderscrolls, Fallout3.
Bungie had Halo 3,4,Reach,ODSt. Epic had Gears 1-4, Shadow complex
Sega had sleepers like Vanquish, Valkaria Choronicles.
To even answer this question as a REAL gamer, it would take a long time to sit down and review all the games you played thru.
If you a biased fanboy, you'd run in here and be like "Naughtydawg" and call it a day while you wait for Knack. Its really hard to say for me. I'll have to get back to this thread.