I agree with everything you said especially the stuff about Woodson. If he would of just let Amare play earlier they would of made the playoffs. My only reason for taking Bosh at this point is he doesn't get hurt and with Amare you are always wondering if this is the game his career ends.
Overall career though STAT >>>>>>>>>>>> Bosh and it's not even close. Bosh was the best player on a team that never made the playoffs in the East and STAT helped bring his teams to the Conference Finals in the West.

I think prime Amare > Bosh but there is absolutely no way Amare had a better career than Bosh, that makes no sense. Bosh just won 2 titles breh, hes a hall of famer at this point