So who is the goat baseball player?

[The War Report]

Don't be silly. Bonds juiced and before the 98 season (the season he started juicing), Griffey was better across the board minus stolen bases. They're equal IMO and Pujols?

.325 .415 .611 1.026 wOBA .426 wRC+ 165

473 HR's and counting.


He's clearly a HOF player and if he continues to hit like that he'll be top 5.

 

[Walter H White]

If we're ignoring PED use, then during my fandom (1987-current), it's between....

 

[malbaker86]

.325 .415 .611 1.026 wOBA .426 wRC+ 165

473 HR's and counting.


He's clearly a HOF player and if he continues to hit like that he'll be top 5.

You didn't see my edit. I changed my post to say that I think Griffey is better NOW than pujols but by the time Pujols finishes he should end up the better player

 

[Scottie Drippin]

All players pre-integration shall not be considered.

End of.

Not a coincidence that there isn't a single white GOAT candidate post-Robinson (not counting Ted as he was playing already at the time).

 

[The War Report]

You didn't see my edit. I changed my post to say that I think Griffey is better NOW than pujols but by the time Pujols finishes he should end up the better player

Griffey now is not a better hitter than Pujols.

 

[malbaker86]

Griffey now is not a better hitter than Pujols.

Who said that??? Pujols will NEVER be the fielder that Griffey was. Not even close

 

[The War Report]

Who said that??? Pujols will NEVER be the fielder that Griffey was. Not even close

You're overrating his fielding.

 

[Real]

so Babe Ruth?

Maybe if this was 1996, cac.

 

[mr. smoke weed]

bonds

 

[GoddamnyamanProf]

Maybe if this was 1996, cac.

lol at you not even understanding the point of my post

cac

 

[HookersandIceCream]

Pujols has a better

Batting Average
On Base %
Slugg %
OPS
OPS+

Griffeys career averages are equal to Pujols WORST season

Pujols averages more hits, home runs, walks and strikes out a lot less per 162 games

Pujols has more Wins above replacement value(both fangraphs and baseball reference) in the time he played NOW than Griffey accumulated in his entire career

 

[Real]

lol at you not even understanding the point of my post

cac

I understood VERY well, cac

 

[malbaker86]

You're overrating his fielding.

idk bruh. 10 Gold Gloves are hard to "overrate" but

 

[The War Report]

idk bruh. 10 Gold Gloves are hard to "overrate" but

And Pujols 2 which tells me that he can field his position better than most first basemen.

 

[GoddamnyamanProf]

I understood VERY well, cac

Don't think ya did, cac