Did you not just bring up wins and losses? Carr and Rivers were not playing one on one. W-L records are team stats. Carr has played well but he still has a beast in Amari Cooper and a balanced offense. He has one of the best lines in the league. Not to mention short passes that get taken to the house where the receiver does all the work. All of that is taken into account when I grade QBs. Rivers is top 5 right now...Carr isn't...he may be down the road but I won't be taking W-L into account just like I wasn't last year when he played.
So who's your top 5 QBs in the NFL right now
- Thread starter PremierDaTruth
- Start date
Did you not just bring up wins and losses? Carr and Rivers were not playing one on one. W-L records are team stats. Carr has played well but he still has a beast in Amari Cooper and a balanced offense. He has one of the best lines in the league. Not to mention short passes that get taken to the house where the receiver does all the work. All of that is taken into account when I grade QBs. Rivers is top 5 right now...Carr isn't...he may be down the road but I won't be taking W-L into account just like I wasn't last year when he played.
andy dalton stats and wins, tom brady stats and wins, arron rodgers stats and wins, palmer stats and wins, but yaw wanna bring up bum ass peyton manning to make your argument look better.
we docking carr for having weapons now?
but he only throwing short passes where the receivers do all the work. yaw nikkas kill me.
Last edited:
28 Gramz
How U Luv That???
but he only throwing short passes where the receivers do all the work. yaw nikkas kill me.
Raiders gonna be a problem in the next couple years.
PremierDaTruth
Oh well.
Rivers is around 7 for me.
no doubt. Tom Brady makes(and has made) a living off of short passes, and has arguably the greatest weapon in the NFL at his disposal.
but he only throwing short passes where the receivers do all the work. yaw nikkas kill me.
dora_da_destroyer
Master Baker
this would be my list, not really in this order but yea.
this list should also show why people need to kill all that noise about tossing middle of the road QB's in the bushes so quickly, elite QB's don't grow on trees.
dora_da_destroyer
Master Baker
that same playoff prowess as peyton manning, philip rivers, and matt ryan
meanwhile, never regular season top 5 cats like eli and flacco beast in the offs....all of which means, what does failing in the offs have to do with your ranking during the season and quality of play? you can't knock someone off the list simply because they don't have playoff success...we're not talking all time GOAT's we talking top 5 qb'ing right now
Rivers is constantly fukking overrated son. Top 5 in the league? Dude couldn't complete a pass more than 8 yards down the fukking field against us. Gaudy numbers. shyt productionWho is better? Derek fukking Carr?
Rivers 70% completion percentage, leads league in yards and 2nd in td's but not top 5.
@JLova whats wrong with these dudes.
Born2BKing
Veteran
1st in the league in yards and 2nd in td's, with 70% completion percentage is shytty production in 2015?
dora_da_destroyer
Master Baker
Are you going to give any evidence of why he should be top 5 or you just fishing for daps by mentioning another black QB?
1. A Gawd Rodgers
2. Brady
.
3. Big Ben
.
.
4. Rivers
5. Romo
2. Brady
.
3. Big Ben
.
.
4. Rivers
5. Romo
NOSaintsFan02
Superstar
Guess Brees gonna have to throw 7 more TDs in a game again before yall stop disrespecting him 
DonKnock
KPJ Gonna Save Us
You gotta play well against good teams to be an elite QB. Can't have guys who are only putting up huge numbers against the Texans, Bucs, Lions, etc be in that consideration 
1.Brady
2. Dalton
3. Rodgers
4. Cam
5. Ben
H.M. Brees
1.Brady
2. Dalton
3. Rodgers
4. Cam
5. Ben
H.M. Brees
Last edited:
Originalgangsta317
Banned
Kapernick 
