I. If you agree that they're on the same tier, why did you make this thread?Agreed.
I give wall the nod,because he's a better defender by a great margin and has proven he can do it as the top guyAnd also like you said his scoring is coming along now.
Coli nikkas live in the moment and flip flop like crazy. Whachu expect?
Next week after Wall drops 30/15 they'll call him a top 3 PG![]()
I. If you agree that they're on the same tier, why did you make this thread?
II. You're overrating and overvaluing Wall's defense - he's been wildly inconsistent this season - which is to be expected with his workload
III. Wall has NOT proven he can lead a team as the top guy. Not to mention on a general scale, Kyrie has proven himself to be a 1b option on a title team. Whereas Wall's postseason resume has been largely underwhelming.
Wall's outperformed him this season, and there certainly is an argument for him being the better player (not that nonsense you typed in the OP). But at the end of the day, there's no definitive margin in favor of Wall that would warrant you making this thread. I'm not surprised though, since you believed Rondo was better than Kyrie not too long ago and cited the fact that 'Rondo was the better leader, playmaker, defender and rebounder'; hanging your argument on what the box score told you rather than valuing impact v skillset v role.
Same ole story.
I don't dap Gil-Scott, but when I do, I'll post this comment![]()
Till wall wins a finals like kyrie.
This will not be taken as real.
Regardless of the numbers or an eye test looking in wall's favor
Art Barr
What? Man stop,Lebron is responsible for that,Wall is the better two way player,and though he hasn't won a ring he has been the best player on his team each time they've made the playoffs,you crazy if you think Wall doesn't have an argument for being better than Kyrie.
Well if you believe they're on the same tier, why did you make this thread? Look at how you phrased the thread title and the OP. You're making it seem like Wall is on another level and that it's comical if anybody thinks Kyrie is better. I don't know about you, but players on the same tier are usually within proximity of each other - certainly not the differential you laid out in this thread.They are on the same tier,i never said they weren't,Wall is just better
Except it's not.Wall's defense is still alot better than Kyrie's tho,regardless if it's inconsistent,his inconsistent nights on D,is better than Kyrie's consistent nights.
That's because Wall had a better support cast than Kyrie did (before LeBron's return), when he went to the playoffs.Ok but every time the Wizards have went to the playoffs while Wall has been there,Wall has been the best player,no question.
Starting a team from scratch? I'm taking Kyrie. No question.Ok point blank. You starting a team,you taking Kyrie or Wall?
What? Man stop,Lebron is responsible for that,Wall is the better two way player,and though he hasn't won a ring he has been the best player on his team each time they've made the playoffs,you crazy if you think Wall doesn't have an argument for being better than Kyrie.
I. If you agree that they're on the same tier, why did you make this thread?
II. You're overrating and overvaluing Wall's defense - he's been wildly inconsistent this season - which is to be expected with his workload
III. Wall has NOT proven he can lead a team as the top guy. Not to mention on a general scale, Kyrie has proven himself to be a 1b option on a title team. Whereas Wall's postseason resume has been largely underwhelming.
Wall's outperformed him this season, and there certainly is an argument for him being the better player (not that nonsense you typed in the OP). But at the end of the day, there's no definitive margin in favor of Wall that would warrant you making this thread. I'm not surprised though, you believed Rondo was better than Kyrie not too long ago and cited the fact that 'Rondo was the better leader, playmaker, defender and rebounder'; hanging your argument on what the box score told you rather than valuing impact v skillset v role.
Same ole story.
00000000000000000000000000000022
I come from Chicago.
This whole shyt is deflection cause you know what time it is..
First off if bron is responsible solely for the cavs winning a title.
Then why are the cavs not repeat champs.
So let us stop right there.
For you to discount kyrie's performance on the grand stage in the endgame.
I just can not even honor what you have to say about wall versus kyrie.
As it is not even welled in the whole truth and actual complete facts.
Not to mention, what happened tonight.
Just for starters even after the whole pr the game and comparison and false praise even on the jump for wall over kyrie if we take the former Mr heat island's idea of who wall is.
So stop,...kyrie is that dude and the best pg in the league because of that performance.
The other guards of their Gen are going to have to play with another great player and then rise above.
To meet their great teammate and kyrie did that.
So till someone else does that...nobody is gonna honor the wall comparative as an idea.
Till wall galvanizes a group to best what kyrie did and in the circumstances.
or in a dominating manner where game seven is never reached.
Wall will not be honored as better than Kyrie.
Regardless, of what the eye test or stats say.
Till that occurs, period.
Art Barr
Well if you believe they're on the same tier, why did you make this thread? Look at how you phrased the thread title and the OP. You're making it seem like Wall is on another level and that it's comical if anybody thinks Kyrie is better. I don't know about you, but players on the same tier are usually within proximity of each other - certainly not the differential you laid out in this thread.
Except it's not.
That's because Wall had a better support cast than Kyrie did (before LeBron's return), when he went to the playoffs.
Kyrie's rookie season (age 19) he was running with the corpse of Jamison (2nd option - age 35), the corpse of Parker (age 36), Casspi, Gee and Varejao (who only played 25 games).
Kyrie's second season (age 20 - only played 59 games) he was running with Waiters' bum ass (2nd option - age 21), TT (age 21), Zeller and Gee.
Kyrie's third season (age 21) he was running with Waiters' bum ass again (2nd option), Deng (only played 40 games), TT, Hawes (who only played 27 games)
Meanwhile, Wall had teammates like Ariza, Gortat, Nene and Beal when the Wizards went to the playoffs, and this was when he was 23 and 24. Wall wasn't leading teams anywhere when he was 19, 20 and 21 - the same ages as Kyrie before LeBron returned.
Starting a team from scratch? I'm taking Kyrie. No question.