SOHH we gonna act like MBDTF isn't a.....

[Harry B]

But foreal tho I wouldn't call it a classic but damn near ever song was piff!
Woulda been more dope if Christian Dior Denim Flow made the actual album.

Where would Christian Dior Denim Flow fit in? And in which way?
Every song is connected on the album and has the same overall feeling.
CDDF is a dope ass joint, but don't see how it would add anything to the album.

 

[Zach Lowe]

I can't call it a classic just because Kanye conspicuously tried to make a classic and got the critics excited, who in turn rewarded him by calling it a classic

Musically I prefer his first two albums

If it's a classic then it's a classic that I never listen to

Yeah the production was pretty dense and shyt... but who cares if I don't care about the songs and what they're saying

 

[JMurder]

I can't call it a classic just because Kanye conspicuously tried to make a classic and got the critics excited, who in turn rewarded him by calling it a classic

 

[Zach Lowe]

So are we gonna act like pop music critics rate music intelligently?

Stop it 5

The only genre that has decent critics is probably classical because there are qualifications for critiquing it

 

[Tetris v2.0]

Most overrated album ever. By lightyears. Critics literally said this album brought them to tears and had out-of-body experiences n shyt

Good album, great album even. But Jesus...

 

[Brad Piff]

great album but not classic

 

[Zach Lowe]

If Dark Fantasy (the album) had sounded like Watch the Throne (if it had the same songs) but still had that hype and excessive critic baiting that Dark Fantasy had, it would've gotten the same reviews

It's not about music for these critics

 

[Funcrusher]

Sure another thread about a 'classic' album. When did this come out again?

And @ threadtitle, FOH with that "are we gonna act like" shyt.

 

[Sucka Free]

mBDTF and 808's the only 2 kanye albums I didn't like. I even like WTT.

 

[Maliciouslarynx]

Good Album. Hell of a Life instrumental is serious, but overall it's just a weak track to me.

 

[feelosofer]

It's his 3rd best album imo, but yeah definitely one of the definitive albums of this era.

 

[954UAlreadyknow]

Most overrated album ever on here. Album is average as fukk

 

[Boolean]

Ye has not dropped one non-classic album in their respective genres.

 

[Rarely-Wrong Liggins]

Yes, yes we are.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I997 using Tapatalk 2

 

[OG Talk]

A top 10 album of the 2000's.

Albums from the 2000's that are better imo...

The Chronic
Black on Both Sides
Like Water For Chocolate
The Black Album
The Blue Print
American Gangster
College Dropout
Stankonia
Speaker Boxxx Love Below
Get Rich or Die Trying
Stillmatic
Surpeme Clientele
The Fix
Only Built For Cuban Linx 2
Thug Motivation
Last of a Dying Breed
BE
Distant Relatives
Untitled
Deeper Than Rap
Life Is Good
Trap Music
R.A.P. Music
Late Registration
The Cool
Food and Liquor