As the "cosigner" let me jump in here
At the end of the day - it's Wacky's list. I applaud him for taking the time and effort to make it. Obviously, when judging things like "quality" and "impact" his subjective opinions are going to play a critical role.
If I were to do a list, or if @StillNotSoft were to do a list - 40 would be on there and Too $hort would be higher. Juelz wouldn't be on there (and at least for me) neither would Jim Jones.
We need to do a better job of defining the term "regional". Back in the early 90s hip-hop was mostly regional in that you could get all day air play from your local radio station but be ignored everywhere else. There were also distinctive sounds associated with different regions. At this point - the radio is largely identical nationwide and certain regions have lost their identity (NY is a prime example).
The Bay does still have a distinct sound (I'm basing this off listening to the latest E-40/Too $hort album - which sounds drastically different from everything else on the radio).
@StillNotSoft - I gotta disagree with you about Jay, Cam and AZ being regional artists when their first albums dropped. But then again - maybe we're using the term differently? I do agree with you that nationwide - most fans of the music would be able to identify E-40's singles over Juelz. That's just my opinion.
You also gotta wonder to what extent young fans nowadays are still rooting for their home teams?
since you want to jump back in as "the cosigner", would you care to acknowledge the reason he brought you up as the cosigner? he said you werent from the bay.....BUT YOU ARE......AND YOU CONVENIENTLY DIDNT ADDRES THIS.
e-40, nor his singles are as identifiable as juelz santana. lol.
the only e-40 single thats even identifiable years later to those who arent e-40 fans is "U & That". and hes the least identifiable person on that record, behind t-pain & kandi........and to go further, t-pain is the reason that the song is identifiable.
Cosignsns can't hurthe seem like a sensible poster to me....and stop it,u can't possibly think most of the sales from a platinum artist is coming from the bay,not even close....that math works for independent nikkas only who can eat very well in the bay.....but u gotta be kiddin me to think a gold or platinum bay artist is sellin majority of those albums in the bay....thing with the bay is u got people who are fans of bay area music bcuz of the sound with the heavy bass,funk sound and the game spittin and now hyphy who are not from the bay.......the bay area tag holds more weight then people give it credit for but all them sales ain't from the bay bruh....but from fans of the sound and the tradition
....either way that doesn't define regional....now nikkas like JayZ with RD,Camron,AZ,them nikkas wuz local and went gold,Jada with his last album still went gold,I think big l went gold....40's name rang more bells than most of them nikkas early on as wuz the whole point of the controversy....if he wuznt gettin play outside the bay folks wouldna had to go out they way to hate on that man.
Even Jacka who is a bay staple put out a independent album that did decent but most of the sales ain't come from the bay....that's folk lore shyt possibly promoted by bay area nikkas as a pat on the back...but its obvious bullshyt...I did mine now name these bay area artist who wuz goin gold and plat that u think majority of the sales came from the bay.....yet other big name bay nikkas hot as hell in the bay couldn't sniff it or half of it in most cases
Casual fans may not think most of those e40 songs is classic outside of Tell Me When to Go and U and That.........but they damn sure don't think them Juelz songs is either and probaly wouldn't even know what the hell u talkin about if u bought up them songs....say Whistle Song and they gon say "Ying Yang twins?"....now ask about U and Dat Booty,ask about Tell Me when to go....and don't say the name of the artist and see who can identify the person behind the songs.....most people can tell u them e40 songs.....when's the last time u heard Whistle Song or Oh Yes on your radio stations coli...get in here,stand up....time to end this argument.
...when they come in here and bogard u with cosigns u might have to change shyt up,if u really "do it for the nikkas
"...get in here yall
i didnt say anything was wrong with a cosign, but you seem to put too much stock in it.
i dont know what youre definition of most is. im not saying that a whopping 90% of bay area sales come from the bay area. but their homebase sales push them further than any other homebase in this game. and this has been an established well-known fact for practically 2 decades now. e-40 will tell you this himself. im sure hes already on record. i know for a fact that there are people from the bay who are on-record talking about this as this has been well-documented for the longest. theres articles and everything. i know youre a homer, but please dont tell me that youre a non-cognizant one.
these are the names youre listing?


trust me dog, nobody who isnt a fan of dude thinks of e-40's "tell me when to go" or "U & dat" as classics. nobody even remembers them aside from the white folks that still jam to "u & that".


Last edited by a moderator: