we're not judging singing talent, tons of singers created hits without talent, and tons of talent who can't create hits. janet and madonna were never great singers and absolutely abolished charts while mariah and whitney used once in a lifetime voices to do the same. at the end of the day singles charted, records sold, tour size, and influence spoke to where they stood in the music HOF, not their voices
Is the song a banger or nah? Lol. That’s what people gonna care about. People love hearing Rihanna’s voice on songs. Of course she can’t sing great. Lol.
Mary could hang with Mariah. Mariah has more pop hits but if the audience is mostly black I bet Mary can go toe to toe
Son u skipping Janet? Lol. Mariah ain’t washing no damn Janet Jackson.
Nah not at all. I think Mary, Mariah and Janet could all go either way tbh. Only one that doesn’t belong with them is Toni. Most of her best shyt was in a short amount of time
This is the list I made for Janet real quick of the top.
He didn’t get washed. He left out mad songs too. It was a dope battle and honestly the discrepancy between Mariah and Janet is NOT that high at all. The black community is DEF gonna be rockin wit Janet over Mariah real talk. Janet changed the game fam and I know u peeped that list I showed u. And I ain’t even include feature shyt like What’s It Gonna Be.
For Mary I got:
