The Coli Official Boxing Controversial Decision Thread

[surv2syn]

this pissed me off so much...I wouldn't have even blinked if Andrade took a swing at the ref after the bell...bute got the equivalent a 20 count man

people dont like to hear this but it was blatent cheating. Wright isnt even a good actor. Get in your corner! Get in your corner! Now!!! all that shyt wont necessary.

 

[patscorpio]

Nah it wasn't neumann that wanted to restart the fight it was Abraham's promoter..miranda broke that jaw with one punch and they tried to say it was a foul so they could stop the fight on a TD. When that wasn't the case they told Abraham to continue. That alone was a stupid decision. To fight a murderous prime punching Miranda for another 7 rounds with a severely broken jaw. Abraham could have had his career ended that night. They were on the bullshyt with the point deductions and fukkery. I do have to give Abraham his props for surviving. I was cringing everytime Miranda was landing on it. Blood and shyt flying everywhere . Any other country and Miranda would have been middleweight champion that night.

Abraham-Miranda I

Randy (Alfred E. ) Neuman stopped the fight...then when he learned Abraham would lose the fight based on stoppage from a punch that broke his jaw, he re-started the damn fight and deducted 2 points from Miranda.

He later deducted 2 more points from Miranda. The crazy thing is, the judges had Abraham winning without the 4 point deduction. Thats when I knew Abraham was protected like hell.

 

[Black Gatsby]

how so breh?

Since Groves I really really disliked Froch so I've been analysing.

Rewatched a number of fights including Ward (that fight was a near shutout, some ridiculous scoring in that!) and when watching Dirrell whilst rocking him late he didn't do anywhere near enough to win and was pretty negative.
I appreciate good boxing, fighting on the back foot etc but Dirrell wasn't doing that and it's weird because upon seeing it first time round that's what I thought happened.
I remember it was on a ppv channel over here but they fukked up and gave it away free so when the fight finished I called my bro at like 5am when it finished telling him Dirrell was robbed, a few years later I'm more meh, he could have done more.

 

[Black Gatsby]

people dont like to hear this but it was blatent cheating. Wright isnt even a good actor. Get in your corner! Get in your corner! Now!!! all that shyt wont necessary.

Can't go wrong with Marlon B Wright!

 

[patscorpio]

Also...

Ricky Hatton got a gift against Collazo.

And Cotto my dude, but he didn't beat Clottey IMO

im torn on cotto-clottey..on one hand clottey should have gotten the nod..but in the other hand I bet on a UD and SD for Cotto specifically ..so I couldn't be too outraged

 

[Black Gatsby]

im torn on cotto-clottey..on one hand clottey should have gotten the nod..but in the other hand I bet on a UD and SD for Cotto specifically ..so I couldn't be too outraged

Was in the Garden for that, flew to NY from London for my 21st bday.

Thought it was close but Clottey let the fight get away from him. No robbery for me.

 

[patscorpio]

Was in the Garden for that, flew to NY from London for my 21st bday.

Thought it was close but Clottey let the fight get away from him. No robbery for me.

without the KD that fight would have potentially been a split decision draw or clottey would have won that SD based on the final judges card

 

[Black Gatsby]

without the KD that fight would have potentially been a split decision draw or clottey would have won that SD

Knocked down by a jab He was furious I remember.

The cut fukked with Cotto too

 

[Black Gatsby]

That Cotto Clottey fight was too great! The Cotto judo throw, Cotto backing Clottey into the corner throwing the kitchen sink at him and Clottey giving him the "In Ghana that is what we call tickling" head shake

 

[patscorpio]

Winky Wright vs. Fernando Vargas was always one that irritated me. Haven't watched it since fight night, but remember hearing the decision for Vargas and being .

I felt the same way with vargas-quartey..2 of the fukking judges had vargas winning very wide on that shyt which had me like ..that was some bullshyt


on an unrelated note..154 was the shyt to watch in the 90s and early 00s...they all fought each other

 

[patscorpio]

That Cotto Clottey fight was too great! The Cotto judo throw, Cotto backing Clottey into the corner throwing the kitchen sink at him and Clottey giving him the "In Ghana that is what we call tickling" head shake

it was..cotto was in no hurry to rematch clottey after that lol

 

[patscorpio]

of more recent times
Brandon Rios vs Richar Abril
I would like to sit down with the judges and ask them what the fukk were they watching that night to actually give Rios more than one round in that fight. Hell even giving Rios one round in that fight would have been a stretch. Abril blanked him IMO. Rios was too weight drained to do anything and Abril boxed the shyt out of him.

 

[surv2syn]

Winky Wright vs. Fernando Vargas was always one that irritated me. Haven't watched it since fight night, but remember hearing the decision for Vargas and being .

I guessed I wasnt really pissed or shocked because I knew Winky was gonna get jerked. What POed me was when Vargas refused to give him a rematch. Then when Vargas wasnt hot no more and Winky was undisputed, Vargas was "begging" Winky to come and fight him again if he wanted to prove he really won the first time.

Winky was like

























:weredone:

 

[firemanBk]

I was on another board during the Lara-William fight. Williams was getting his ass beat so bad, people were calling for him to retire after the fight. You here to decision is announced & it's a MD for Paul Williams. Everyone knows Williams lost that.

That decision blew my mind. I know there are robberies but this was the most blatant fixed decision in the history of pro boxing imo. NOBODY and I mean NOBODY though P-Will won that fight outside of 2 judges (nobody had him even drawing outside of that 3rd judge either). The possibility of a robbery didn't even enter my mind because Lara whipped his ass so thoroughly that I didn't think it was possible for a judge to even more than 4 rounds to Paul.

 

[patscorpio]

sergio martinez vs kermit cintron
Words cannot describe the fukkery in this fight. Sergio controlled that fight from jump. sergio KO'ed kermit man. it was a clean left hand that dropped him not a headbutt. ref counts to ten while Kermit is on that canvas bytchin as the bell rang. That is a knockout. You cannot be saved by the bell in any round. Then the ref restarts the fight for no fukking reason . Sergio again beat that ass to the final bell. One judge i remembered had that shyt wide and rightfully so but 2 judges scored that shyt a draw..a draw?!!! ...fukking ridiculous..kermit was over there celebrating like a damn fool