the debate of Tom Brady vs. Manning is over now right?
- Thread starter Jparker
- Start date
954UAlreadyknow
All Star
Basically the rings argument in football is dumb
I don't even wanna keep having these discussions its ridiculous
Carlos Huerta
Just keep my rep red
how about playoff records? is that also dumb too?
The debate been over Brady>>>>Manning, both will be in the HoF and both have been standard bearers for a long time, its time to let this go
Amare's Right Hook
Southeast World Champion
Tom never hooked it up with pizza so yeah, its a wrap
So Peyton didn't wet the bed all those years the defense was actually good. Including the championship year?
The length the people go to constantly put Manning head and shoulders above Brady is
Funny how Brady and Peyton won Chips when they had top flight defenses. I wonder if there's a link to good defensive teams winning Super Bowls...hmmm????
I know yall hate Peyton but the lengths yall go to discredit one and prop up the other is pathetic.
Yes. Records are a team stat
The God Poster
LWO representa
Its a fact manning has played horrible in every super bowl he's been in. Not to mention the countless big games in his career.Funny how Brady and Peyton won Chips when they had top flight defenses. I wonder if there's a link to good defensive teams winning Super Bowls...hmmm????
I know yall hate Peyton but the lengths yall go to discredit one and prop up the other is pathetic.
Yes. Records are a team stat
What excuse you give him?
R.E.N. Spells Ren
Veteran
Not saying Brady isn't a great QB but he's a system QB... Period. Bledsoe was doing the same thing until he got hurt... He was traded elsewhere and was sucky. Matt Cassell got some burn and put up Brady numbers that year.
Peyton... While having the arm strength of a T-rex is the better pure QB. Say what you will be he went to the Broncos and still put up numbers & lead them to the SB and playoffs.
Just saying...
Nahhhhh
LOL @ opinion = fact. Only on the Coli.
How did Drew Brees do vs Seattle? Tom Brady? Rodgers? Peyton put up similar numbers (better rating) against Seattle in the SB than Tom did the last time they played. IMO, everyone sucks against that D.
Then against New Orleans dude had 1 TD, 1INT (the pick 6 which was a mistake) and 300+ yards. OMG, how horrible!!!!
Then agains the Bears 1TD, 1INT 250 yards....SO HORRIBLE!
Even that said what a dumb ass argument. Have you watched the greats in the posteason? Do you recall how many crap performances we saw in the postseason from the "greats"?
Brady has had 2 3 pick games and 1 0TD 2pick game and still had a good enough team to shoulder those mistakes and were able to pull out Ws. That's 3 Ws that should have been losses. Peyton never had that luxury. If he didn't perform at an elite level, his team LOST.
If you think Brady's better, then that's fine. No issue with that. But at least come up with legitimate reasons why he is better. Yall come up with some of the most retarded shyt.
Slaimon Khan Shah
SLAIMON KHAN SHAH = SHAOLIN MONK/S OF ISLAAM
May Allah guide Peyton to Islam. It's the only way he will be successful.
It ain't "over" over...not as long as they are still playing.
Let's hypothetically say Brady not only loses SB XLIX, but also Peyton ironically pulls an Elway and wins the next 2(and then probably retires too
). Improbable but not impossible but then the debate is back and it's real.
Let's hypothetically say Brady not only loses SB XLIX, but also Peyton ironically pulls an Elway and wins the next 2(and then probably retires too
). Improbable but not impossible but then the debate is back and it's real.the irony of a kobrick fan posting this.
He's obviously my favorite player but I don't consider Kobe better than MJ or even LeBron so don't know where you're going with this. Nice try though